About two dozen states challenged President Donald Trump's new global tariffs on Thursday, filing a lawsuit against the import taxes he imposed after a tough defeat at the Supreme Court, which declared them illegal.

First modification: 03/05/2026 - 22:06 Last modification: 03/05/2026 - 22:07

The Democratic attorneys general and governors involved in the lawsuit argue that Trump is exceeding his powers with the 15% tariffs planned for much of the world.

Trump has claimed that tariffs are essential to reducing persistent U.S. trade deficits. It imposed these levies under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, after the Supreme Court struck down tariffs it had imposed last year under an emergency powers law.

Section 122, which has never been invoked, allows the president to impose tariffs of up to 15%. These are limited to five months, unless extended by Congress.

The lawsuit is led by the attorneys general of Oregon, Arizona, California and New York.

“The focus now should be on returning people's money, not doubling down with illegal tariffs,” said Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield. The lawsuit comes a day after a judge ruled that companies that paid tariffs under Trump's old framework should receive refunds.

The White House promises a forceful defense

The White House affirmed that Trump is acting within his powers. “The president is using the authority granted to him by Congress to address fundamental problems in international payments and address our country's large and serious balance of payments deficits,” spokesman Kush Desai said. “The Administration will vigorously defend the president's action in court.”

The new lawsuit argues that Trump cannot invoke Section 122 because it was intended to be used only in specific, limited circumstances, not to apply broad taxes on imports. He also argues that tariffs will raise costs for states, businesses and consumers.

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes cited a study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York that found Americans largely bear the cost of the tariffs, estimated at about $1,200 a year per household. “That's money coming out of the pockets of American families trying to buy food, pay rent and keep their small businesses afloat,” Mayes said.

Many of the plaintiff states had also successfully sued over tariffs Trump imposed under another law: the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA).

Four days after the Supreme Court struck down his sweeping IEEPA-based tariffs on February 20, Trump invoked Section 122 to impose 10% tariffs on foreign goods. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant told CNBC on Wednesday that the administration would raise levies to the 15% limit this week.

Democratic states and other critics argue that the president cannot use Section 122 as a substitute for rescinded tariffs to combat the trade deficit.

The legal question surrounding Trump's tariff war

The Section 122 provision is directed at what it calls “fundamental international payments problems.” The question is whether that formulation covers trade deficits, that is, the difference between what the United States sells to other countries and what it buys from them.

Section 122 arose out of the financial crises that appeared in the 1960s and 1970s, when the US dollar was pegged to gold. Other countries were exchanging dollars for gold at a fixed rate, threatening to cause the collapse of the US currency and chaos in financial markets. But the dollar is no longer tied to gold, so critics say Section 122 is obsolete.

Uncomfortably for Trump, his own Justice Department argued in a court brief last year that the president needed to invoke the emergency powers law because Section 122 had “no obvious application” to combating trade deficits, which it called “conceptually distinct” from balance of payments issues.

Still, some legal analysts believe the Trump administration has a stronger case this time.

“The legal reality is that courts will likely grant President Trump considerably more deference regarding Section 122 than they granted his previous tariffs under the IEEPA,” Peter Harrell, a visiting fellow at Georgetown University's Institute of International Economic Law, wrote in a commentary Wednesday.

The New York International Trade Court, which specializes in these types of cases and will hear the states' lawsuit, wrote in its own decision last year that it struck down the tariffs based on emergency powers that Trump did not need them because Section 122 was available to combat trade deficits.

Trump has other legal authorities he can use to impose tariffs, and some have already been tested in court. The tariffs he imposed on Chinese imports during his first term under Section 301 of the same 1974 trade law remain in place.

The attorneys general of Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin, as well as the governors of Kentucky and Pennsylvania, have also joined the lawsuit.

AP

Related keywords

The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.