Donald Trump has gone from calling Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni a "great leader" to claiming that she lacks courage and has let Washington down. The cracks opened by the war in the Middle East deepened with the US president's attacks on Pope Leo XIV, which Meloni described as "unacceptable."
First modification: 04/14/2026 - 23:24
The first signs of dissent from the Government of Giorgia Meloni against the policies of the White House came after the outbreak of the war in the Middle East after the attacks by the US and Israel against Iran.
In an attempt to distance itself from the conflict, Italy in March refused to allow US fighters to use an air base in Sicily for combat operations in Iran.
The Meloni Executive alleged constitutional limitations and maintained that the bilateral security agreement with Washington did not allow authorizations of this type without prior approval from Congress.
However, differences between Rome and Washington escalated this week after the Italian prime minister directly criticized US President Donald Trump for his attacks on Pope Leo XIV.
The Republican president called the head of the Catholic Church "weak on crime" and "terrible in foreign policy" for his pacifist comments about the war in Iran.
Meloni described the verbal attack against the pontiff as "unacceptable," words that prompted a response from Washington.
"She is the one who is unacceptable," Trump said this Tuesday, April 14, in an interview with the newspaper 'Corriere della Sera', in which he accused Meloni of "pretending that the United States do the job for her."
Trump said that the Italian far-right leader "shouldn't talk about war, because she has no idea what's going on."
The president, who praised Meloni in the past with adjectives such as "great leader" or "beautiful", assured that she "is no longer the same person." "I thought I had courage, but I was wrong," he concluded.
Read also “I am not afraid”: Pope Leo XIV after criticism from Trump
On a continental scale, Trump noted that Europe "is destroying itself from within" with its policies.
"They pay the highest energy costs in the world and are not even willing to fight for the Strait of Hormuz, where they receive it. They depend on Donald Trump to keep it open," he said.
The Italian opposition divided before Trump
The US president's criticism of Giorgia Meloni was digested unevenly by the Italian parties, divided between those who close ranks with the Executive and those who predict the end of his political cycle.
"We firmly condemn President Donald Trump's attack on the Prime Minister," said the leader of the Democratic Party (PD) and main opposition force, Elly Schlein, who stressed that, despite political differences, "threats against the Government or against Italy will not be accepted."
On the other side, the former prime minister and leader of Italia Viva, Matteo Renzi, stated that Meloni "is abandoned even by her own, by her guru, by her leader" and warned of accelerated political deterioration. "The collapse has only just begun," he predicted.
To display this content from X (Twitter), you must allow audience measurement and advertising cookies.
The president of the 5 Star Movement, Giuseppe Conte, described the attacks as predictable and questioned the diplomatic strategy of the Government, which he accused of ambiguity in its relationship with Washington.
"He is a Trump who attacks. He attacks left and right. Therefore, the attacks do not surprise me," he said.
Meloni's coalition partner, Vice President and Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani, tried to contain the avalanche of reactions by anticipating that Italy will continue to be a "solid ally" of the United States, but under the principles of "reciprocal loyalty, respect and frankness."
"Until today, President Trump considered Giorgia Meloni a brave person. He was not wrong because she is a woman who never gives up saying what she thinks. And about Pope Leo XIV she has said exactly what all of us, Italian citizens, think," said Tajani.
Italy will not renew defense agreement with Israel
The fight with Trump did not decimate Giorgia Meloni's opposition to the conflict in the Middle East.
This Tuesday, the Italian Prime Minister reported the suspension of the automatic renewal of the memorandum of collaboration with Israel on defense matters due to the "current situation" in the region, she indicated from the 'Vinitaly' wine forum in Verona.
Article nine of the bilateral pact, signed by the parties in 2003, provides for automatic renewal every five years, "as long as neither party" objects to it.
The Italian press assures that this decision was already communicated by the Italian Minister of Defense, Guido Crosetto, to his Israeli counterpart, Israel Katz.
The measure does not come as an isolated event. Meloni has criticized the Israeli authorities for their offensive in the Middle East, to the point of recognizing that in the case of Gaza "the military response" to the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023 "had surpassed any principle of proportionality."
The latest criticism from the Italian Government came on April 8 to demand clarification of the Israeli Army's shooting at an Italian convoy deployed in the United Nations peace mission in Lebanon (UNIFIL).
From Verona, the Italian president claimed the power to contradict her allies: "When you have friends or allies, particularly if they are strategic, you also need to have the courage to say when you don't agree. And that's what I do every day: when I agree I say it, just as when I don't."
With information from EFE, Reuters and local media
Related keywords
The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.




