London (United Kingdom) – The exchange of statements on Iran between Washington and London has revealed ideological differences and governing styles. While Keir Starmer invokes the law to distance himself from the bombings of the United States and Israel, Trump speaks of the "uselessness" of the United Kingdom in the face of the crisis. Is this a breakdown of the transatlantic "special relationship"?
First modification: 03/05/2026 - 04:47
"This government does not believe in regime changes from heaven...We all remember the mistakes of Iraq and have learned from those lessons," British Prime Minister Keir Starmer told parliamentarians on Monday, March 2, two days after the start of the joint US-Israeli attacks against Iran.
It is the first time that Starmer distances himself from President Donald Trump in such direct terms. A few months earlier, differences over the sovereignty of Greenland had begun to give indications of the path that the so-called "special relationship" would take, a term popularized by Winston Churchill in 1944 and which points to the close political, economic and sociocultural alliance between the United Kingdom and the United States.
In the case of Iran, Starmer set his position against Donald Trump and has pointed to a lack of legal bases and a plan in the bombings by the United States and Israel against Iran, which detonated a new war conflict in the Middle East on February 28.
In an appearance in Parliament on Monday, March 2, the premier announced that the United Kingdom will not join the United States or Israel in these bombings, which increased fury in Washington.
However, the friction and annoyance in the White House had begun days before due to the British delay, of "3 or 4 days", in authorizing the use of the Diego García joint military base, located in the Indian Ocean for US interests.
Starmer then relented and gave his approval, but clarified that the use of British military bases or facilities abroad will only be for defense purposes, both for British interests and those of its allies.
Read also Offensive in Iran: satisfied with the support of Berlin, Trump attacks Madrid and London
Very "tense" relationships
British media report that the Government finally authorized the use of the Fairford Air Force base in Gloucestershire, England, and also the Diego García military base, for defense only.
“Relations between London and Washington are more tense than at any time in decades,” says Bence Nemeth, professor of Defense Studies at King's College London, speaking to France 24.
"What I was not prepared to do on Saturday (February 28, when the attacks on Iran began) was for the United Kingdom to join a war unless it was convinced that there was a legal basis and a viable, well-thought-out plan. That remains my position," Starmer emphasized in Parliament on Wednesday.
To display this content from X (Twitter), you must allow audience measurement and advertising cookies.
These have been days in which Starmer, who has been extremely careful in every word and qualifier he uses to refer to the president of the United States and his policies, has left that strategy behind to respond to Trump directly without blushing.
But, despite the crises, for both Washington and London, the bilateral relationship is a priority and has been historically so.
Precisely, the surprise and annoyance of the White House occurs because they expected unrestricted British support, without questioning from its great ally in Europe, at a time when France has maintained a notable distance from Washington.
Read alsoThe attack on a British base in Cyprus: this is how the escalation in Iran borders on the EU
But, the position on Iran seems to have widened the gap between the US and the UK.
"This dispute did not arise in isolation. Relations between Donald Trump and Keir Starmer had already cooled over a number of issues, including disagreements over the future status of the Chagos Islands, Greenland and broader foreign policy differences. The debate over Iran therefore reflects wider political friction within the traditionally close relationship between the UK and the US," Nemeth says.
Meanwhile, Starmer faces more domestic questions, as well as American criticism for his position on Iran. Kemi Badenoch, the head of the Conservative Party, the largest opposition party, not only supports the bombings, but demands more government action to defend the country.
To display this Instagram content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.
"No one wants to see an escalation. The fact is that our bases, in case you haven't noticed, have already been attacked. Iran is trying to kill our soldiers. It (the Government) is catching arrows instead of stopping the archer," Badenoch highlighted after the attack with an Iranian-made drone on a British base in Cyprus.
Read alsoWhat does it mean for Starmer to accept the US request to use British military bases?
"We are not dealing with Winston Churchill"
From the White House and in front of the German Chancellor, Friedrich Merz, Trump went from criticizing the British Government to personal questions in minutes.
"I am not happy with the United Kingdom (...) We are not dealing with Winston Churchill (former British Prime Minister in the 1940s and 1950s)," the US president said at the White House, in a tone of contempt towards Starmer.
According to analysts, it seems that this bilateral “special relationship” is at risk. And a lot has to do with the fact that they are two extremely different personalities.
While Starmer is a lawyer by profession, tremendously attached to the law and essentially a technocrat rather than a politician, Trump is unpredictable, more visceral, and seems to be moved by his feelings and tastes.
“Perhaps it was naive on the part of Number 10 (Downing Street) to present Keir Starmer as a 'Donald Trump whisperer', capable of persuading the unpredictable American president to reverse his reckless decisions,” notes the British newspaper 'The Guardian'.
Although bilateral relations are going through a complex moment, it is unlikely that this situation will have an immediate impact on military, intelligence or economic cooperation.
"The long-term risk lies in political trust. If policymakers in Washington and London increasingly perceive themselves as less reliable partners during crises, this could gradually influence future decisions on defense cooperation, coalition building and strategic planning," explains Nemeth.
"The Prime Minister's legalistic approach to everything is an obstacle to decision-making, to the detriment of the national interest. His initial response was to devise language that did not directly criticize the Americans, but that did not support them either," states an editorial in 'The Telegraph'.
Read alsoThe escalation in Iran spreads: Western countries and the Lebanese militia Hezbollah get involved in the conflict
The weight of the shadow of the war in Iraq
Behind everything remains the British participation in the Iraq war, which remains controversial: 23 years later, its shadow has overshadowed the legacy of former Labor Prime Minister Tony Blair, one of the most popular politicians in the country.
In 2003, Blair supported George W. Bush in the US invasion of Iraq, without strong enough evidence of the presence of nuclear weapons by Saddam Hussein's regime to justify it.
The official investigation, known as Chilcot, concluded in 2016 that the threat of weapons of mass destruction from Iraq was exaggerated to authorize that invasion.
To display this YouTube content, you must allow advertising and audience measurement cookies.
An extension on your browser appears to be blocking the video player from loading. In order to view this content, you must disable it on this site.
"The legacy of the Iraq war plays an important role in shaping British strategic thinking. In the UK, the intervention in Iraq is widely considered a serious political and strategic failure," says Nemeth.
And the Chilcot investigation also revealed Blair's personal loyalty to Bush. Along these lines, Starmer has not only taken political but also personal distance from Trump in the current conflict.
“We all remember the mistakes about Iraq and we have learned those lessons,” Starmer said.
The premier has insisted on the importance of a negotiated solution to the current conflict in the Middle East and has called on the parties to sit down, once again, to dialogue.
With an eye on the elections
Government actions keep one foot in future elections. In the case of Keir Starmer it is more because his weak government is still hurt and involved in the scandal over the appointment of Peter Mandelson as British ambassador in Washington, despite being a friend and ally of the late pedophile Jeffrey Epstein.
In May, Starmer stakes his future in Downing Street. Their challenge is to keep some local governments in London, other areas of England and Scotland under Labor power.
The panorama looks dark. Labor (center-left) has not yet recovered from the loss of the seat for Gorton and Denton, a suburb of Manchester, in the north of England, which was in its power for 100 years and which was taken away by the Greens, allied with the Muslim community, which, in the past, voted for Starmer's formation.
"Labor's resounding defeat in Gorton and Denton demonstrated once again that it is losing Muslim voters. Any suggestion of unilateral support for US action in the Middle East would only serve to further weaken its support," notes the British publication 'The Times'.
Starmer, known for his highly calm decisions, must extremely calculate his next steps both with Trump and internally. Your Government does not have enough strength to allow a mistake.
Read alsoKeir Starmer "fights" to regain control of the Labor Party
Related keywords
The content you requested does not exist or is no longer available.




