This article was initially published on April 4, 2026. – MP Caroline Yadan’s bill aimed at combating anti-Semitism in France is being examined from April 16 in the National Assembly. The elected official affirms that “hatred of the State of Israel is today consubstantial with hatred of the Jews”. Opponents of the text accuse it of essentializing Jews and deliberately confusing anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism.
Published on: 04/04/2026 - 08:29 Modified on: 04/16/2026 - 11:14
It is a text which risks putting the National Assembly in turmoil. Adopted by a narrow majority on January 20 in committee, the bill aimed at “fighting against renewed forms of anti-Semitism” must be examined on Thursday April 16 and Friday April 17 in plenary session.
Supported by Caroline Yadan, deputy for the constituency of French people living abroad encompassing Israel, this PPL (proposed law, in Parliament's jargon) intends to respond to the "explosion of anti-Semitic acts" and its "renewed forms" since the unprecedented terrorist attack by Hamas on October 7, 2023. It is supported by the "central bloc", the right, the far right and a few socialists, including François Hollande and Jérôme Guedj, and strongly contested by the rest of the left, who see it as an amalgamation between Jews and Israel and an attempt to curb any criticism of the policies of the Israeli government led by Benjamin Netanyahu.
For 25 years, anti-Semitic acts "have never been as high as during the last three years", according to the Ministry of the Interior. Between 2023 and 2024, they quadrupled. And if they decreased by 16% to 1,320 in 2025, this figure remains at "a historically high level", anti-Semitic acts accounting for 53% of all anti-religious acts, even though French Jews, estimated between 450,000 and 500,000, represent less than 1% of the country's population.
Also read “We remove the yarmulke”: after October 7, French Jews face the anti-Semitic outbreak
“Today, anti-Jewish hatred in our country is nourished by obsessive hatred towards Israel, which is regularly delegitimized in its existence and criminalized. This phenomenon is exacerbated by extreme minds who, under the pretext of expressing their hatred towards a State, are the instigators of a reinvented anti-Semitism, which we could describe as 'geopolitics'", advances the explanatory memorandum of the proposal of law, which is based on the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of anti-Semitism.
Itself controversial and considered dangerous by the League for Human Rights, this definition states that anti-Semitism corresponds to "a certain perception of Jews which can manifest itself in hatred towards them" which can notably "manifest itself in attacks against the State of Israel when it is perceived as a Jewish community" or by "the establishment of comparisons between contemporary Israeli policy and that of the Nazis".
See alsoIsrael “uses the anti-Semitism card”, says UN expert Francesca Albanese
The bill from Caroline Yadan, who left the Ensemble pour la République group (the Renaissance deputies) due to Emmanuel Macron's recognition of the State of Palestine, expands the offense of advocating terrorism, sanctions the presentation of acts of terrorism as legitimate resistance, creates an offense of negating a State and apologizing for its destruction or negation, and extends the offense of contesting the Shoah, in particular by sanctioning "the comparison of the State of Israel to Nazi regime" which "would therefore be sanctioned as an outrageous trivialization of the Shoah".
During the 40th dinner of the Crif (Representative Council of Jewish Institutions of France), on February 19, Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu promised an examination of the text in April in Parliament, after a postponement at the end of January, affirming that to call "for the destruction of the State of Israel is to call for the vital endangerment of a people". He notably judged that the slogan "From the sea to the Jordan", chanted during pro-Palestinian demonstrations, amounted to calling for "the disappearance of Israel".
However, it is particularly for this type of assessment that the text is controversial. “If its purpose is incontestable, its current writing raises real concerns on the legal, constitutional and political levels,” judged in committee, on January 20, the socialist deputy Marietta Karamanli.
“From the sea to the Jordan”, “anti-Zionism”: terms with multiple contours
Because the expression “From the sea to the Jordan”, which is also used by the Israeli right and extreme right, covers different meanings. Some see it as a slogan for Palestinian rights and their desire for freedom, justice and equality throughout the territory; others see it as a slogan in favor of a single, binational state where Israelis and Palestinians would coexist; others, finally, like Hamas which has adopted this slogan for its own purposes, see it as a call for the destruction of Israel.
"This bill completely disproportionately extends attacks on freedom of expression and leaves room for arbitrariness. When we add, to the apology of terrorism, the fact of 'implicitly' provoking acts of terrorism, it is a very vague notion. Apology means that we do it in a precise way, that we want to persuade that it is a good thing", underlines Nathalie Tehio, president of the Human Rights League (LDH), contacted by France 24
Read alsoBehind the veneer of de-demonization, anti-Semitism still present at the National Rally
Faced with a text that they consider "dangerous" and "liberticidal", several personalities have published articles in recent weeks calling on deputies to reject the Yadan bill.
In Libération, on January 22, a collective of citizens of Jewish origin, including Rony Brauman (ex-president of Médecins sans frontières) and Pierre Tartakowsky (honorary president of the Human Rights League), affirms that "the text maintains the false assimilation between Jews, Israel and Zionism".
"Zionism is a political ideology that dates from the end of the 19th century, with multiple variants ranging from the extreme left to the extreme right that currently governs in Israel. Criticizing Zionism, like any political ideology, is part of the normal democratic debate, while anti-Semitism, like all racism, is an offense that must be fought and punished. To conflate the two is to call into question the democratic freedom to debate and weaken the fight against anti-Semitism, which cannot be confused with the defense of a barbaric policy carried out by a State", we can read.
Read alsoLFI accused of anti-Semitism: a new slip-up which annoys even internally
In Le Monde, on January 25, a group of academics, including Jean-Christophe Attias (historian and philosopher, director of studies at the École Pratique des Hautes Études), Bertrand Badie (politist) and Étienne Balibar (philosopher), warns against "the adoption of legal measures which endanger our freedoms".
“Those of us who are political sociologists and anthropologists would like to express our dismay at the formulation of this proposed law, in particular when it tends to assimilate the use of the term 'resistance' to an apology for terrorism. While the job of researcher consists precisely of making political violence intelligible and objectifying, such a law would criminalize any effort at historical and sociological contextualization,” warns the forum.
The essentialization of Jews at the heart of the argument of both camps
Caroline Yadan disputes that her bill could limit criticism of the State of Israel. "Contrary to rumors and erroneous statements circulating, this bill is not intended to prohibit criticism of a government. It in no way limits support for the Palestinian people. It does not attack an opinion, a cause, or a political commitment. It is not intended to place a State, a government or a foreign policy sheltered from democratic debate. It does not call into question freedom of opinion, freedom of conscience, or freedom of expression – including when this expression is radical, disturbing or deeply critical", she assures in an interview published on February 22 by Le Point.
“In a climate where anti-Jewish hatred thrives on amalgamation and collective attribution, such rhetoric has serious consequences. Tolerating the idea of the destruction of a State amounts to essentializing a people and trivializing hostility against them,” she adds.
Opponents of the text believe, for their part, that it is on the contrary Caroline Yadan's proposed law which essentializes Jews by automatically linking them to Israel.
“It is your words and your bill that assimilate Jews to the State of Israel. You essentialize our Jewish compatriots by assigning them to the politics of the State of Israel, ignoring the diversity of their political opinions, thus fueling the amalgamations that endanger them,” rebellious MP Gabrielle Cathala said in committee.
Also read: Why the promotion of Alfred Dreyfus provokes a debate on his exploitation
An argument supported by the LDH in an article published on January 19 in L'Humanité: "That the Jews of France have a singular relationship of affection for Israel can be rooted in reasons of history, religion, family, etc., but there are a thousand ways of being 'Jewish' and they do not all involve 'ethnic' or religion. The current government of Israel claims this, to the point of having made it a law in 2018. Should France really adopt this vision? Should the Republic really decree that such and such of its citizens are objectively endangered by criticism of a State, at the risk of fueling the worst identity assumptions?
The fundamental law "Jewish nation-state", passed in 2018 by the Knesset, the Israeli Parliament, thus established Israel as "the nation-state of the Jewish people, the national home of the Jewish people who realize their aspiration to self-determination", this right being within the State of Israel "reserved only for the Jewish people".
"The 2018 law in Israel created apartheid by differentiating citizens. And here Caroline Yadan's text goes in the same direction by carrying this essentialist vision, namely the fact that we assimilate Jews to the State of Israel. We are told that Israel is only the Jews, and that the Jews of France necessarily recognize themselves in the State of Israel and in the policy pursued by its government. The risk is the strengthening of anti-Semitism "We must not confuse the policies of Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government with the Jews," denounces Nathalie Tehio.
A petition filed on February 18 on the National Assembly website entitled “No to the Yadan law” has already collected more than 200,000 signatures. The debate in the National Assembly promises to be particularly lively.
Keywords associated with the article
The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.




