Credit, Getty Images
In a letter to the Portuguese king dated March 1696, the then governor of the captaincy of Pernambuco reported the death of Zumbi dos Palmares, "who fought valiantly or desperately" after being cornered by São Paulo bandeirantes in a hiding place.
"The head of the Zumbi was sent to me and I decided to put it on a stick in the most public place in this square [in Recife]", wrote governor Caetano de Melo e Castro to Dom Pedro 2º.
Later, the São Paulo bandeirante Domingos Jorge Velho would report in a letter that Zumbi — the last leader of Quilombo dos Palmares — had been killed in a hiding place by men under his command on November 20, 1695.
Thus, as far as there are records, it was agreed that Zumbi dos Palmares died on November 20th. From December 2023, the date became a national holiday for National Zombie and Black Consciousness Day. By then, it was already a holiday in six states and approximately 1,200 cities in Brazil.
Since the 17th century, studies, books, films and samba-plots have emerged focusing on the biography of Zumbi dos Palmares. But the fact is that practically nothing is known about who this leader really was, says historian Jean Marcel Carvalho França, professor at the Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp).
He is co-author of the book Três Vezes Zumbi, written with Ricardo Alexandre Ferreira. The work explores how different eras created three different "versions" of Zumbi, each one meeting the respective desires of that moment. The predominant version today began to consolidate itself in the 1950s, placing Zumbi as a revolutionary hero.
It is common to reproduce the story that Zumbi dos Palmares was captured as a baby by bandeirantes and handed over to a priest, who baptized him as Francisco and taught the child literacy in Latin and Portuguese. But, at the age of 15, Zumbi fled to Quilombo dos Palmares.
This story was perpetuated by a 1981 book by journalist Décio Freitas, but there is no documentary evidence, says Carvalho França. It was Freitas who also wrote that Zumbi was born in 1655.
End of Most read
It is not even known whether Zumbi was the name of the last leader of the quilombo or whether it was a title in that social organization — in other words, there would have been several "Zumbis" following one another.
But, after all, what is known about this historical figure and November 20th?
Who was Zumbi dos Palmares and how did he die?
Credit, Public Domain
Watch news from Brazil and the world on the BBC World Service
Download here
End of app promotion
Basically, more is known about Zumbi's death than his own life. And what is known about his end comes from the writings of his tormentors — Portuguese and colonial authorities, in addition to the bandeirantes. Therefore, even regarding the date of death and its circumstances, historians are cautious.
For more than a century, based on a 1730 book by Sebastião da Rocha Pita, it was believed that Zumbi had committed suicide, throwing himself off a cliff when he noticed the arrival of invaders.
It was a professor at the end of the 19th century, Mattoso Maia, who brought to light a letter from August 1696 from the Conselho Ultramarino (Portuguese administrative body) that spoke of Zumbi's murder, not suicide.
Letters from governor Caetano de Melo e Castro and bandeirante Domingos Jorge Velho were also found stating that, after the devastation of Quilombo dos Palmares, Zumbi had been cornered and killed — with his head then publicly exposed.
"Everything in history is questionable. Certainties are difficult, because you deal with documents that are imprecise", ponders Carvalho França, particularly highlighting the difficulty of obtaining written documents and, even more so, portraits of people from colonial Brazil.
In other words, by now the reader must have already realized that all the monuments and illustrations — including those that accompany this text — of Zumbi created an image for him, without factual basis.
But, according to the historian, the version that Zumbi was killed by bandeirantes at the behest of the colonial government and that his remains were exposed is "credible" and "plausible".
"It was common to hire bandeirantes to do this type of service. And this exposure of the body in a humiliating way, this is all customary", says the Unesp professor.
More is known about Quilombo dos Palmares, located in Serra da Barriga, in what is currently Alagoas. Especially because this focus of resistance by escaped slaves, formed by several communities, greatly disturbed the authorities — both the Portuguese and the Dutch, during their invasion of the Northeast.
Therefore, many documents were produced by these authorities about the black stronghold that resisted several of their offensives and that caused concern due to its size and organization. The quilombo lasted between approximately 1597 and 1695.
Historical records indicate that Domingos Jorge Velho's troops managed to exterminate the quilombo and, after months of hiding, Zumbi was killed.
According to the letter in which Caetano de Melo e Castro informed the king of having "succeeded in the death of Zumbi", a "mulatto" close to the black leader handed him over to where he was.
"(...) Fearing the said mulatto that he would be punished for his serious crimes, they offered that by guaranteeing his life in my name he would oblige himself to hand over this traitor. He accepted the offer and fulfilled his word by leading the troops to the black man's shack who had already thrown away the little family that accompanied him, leaving only 20 black people, of which he sent 14 to the ambush posts that these people use in their way of war, and going with the six that remained to him to leave. hiding in the sinkhole that he had artificially created, he found the passage taken", says the document.
"He fought valiantly or desperately, killing a man, wounding others and not wanting to surrender or his companions, it was necessary to kill them and only one was left alive (...)."
How did November 20th become so important?
Far beyond the documentary records, what was later produced about Zumbi is a story in itself — explored by the authors of Três Vezes Zumbi.
The first version of Zumbi analyzed in the book was the one produced by his contemporaries and by those who wrote in the following decades, still in Colonial Brazil. But the main focus here was the quilombo itself, which represented a point of instability for the captaincy of Pernambuco and was of interest from a military perspective. During this period, many treated Zumbi as a title, and not a person.
The second version, built throughout the 19th century, addressed the formation of Brazil as a nation in search of an identity. And those who dominated this construction believed in the superiority of European civilization, therefore elevating Domingos Jorge Velho to the role of hero who defeated a focus of barbarism, led by Zumbi.
The third version is the current one: consolidated approximately in the 1950s, it elevates Zumbi to the role of hero and representative of the struggles of the oppressed against the oppressors.
"A hero is a legitimate construction. All people do this. He must be able to function as an aggregator", points out Carvalho França, indicating that a hero embodies societies' projections and ideals.
In the 1970s, the black movement in Rio Grande do Sul, and later nationally, began to use November 20th as a day to raise awareness and pay tribute to Zumbi dos Palmares.
Little by little, the date gained prominence and overlapped with May 13th, previously celebrated as a milestone for the black population. On that day, in 1888, Princess Isabel signed the Áurea Law, which abolished slavery throughout the national territory.
The white monarch, once seen as a heroine for this act, had her role as savior reformulated by the new narratives of history.
Discover more
Watch
End of Watch




