Image Source, X/S.Jaishankar

Nepal's PM Balen Shah has reached India. His visit to India is of about 25 hours. If we look at the mutual relations between the two countries, this period may seem short in that respect, but experts are calling this visit very important.

Balen Shah, who came to power this year after Nepal's 'Gen Z movement', is in India on his first bilateral foreign visit. Before this he had addressed the UN General Assembly in New York.

Experts say that Shah's visit is also important in this regard because most of the political forces that emerged after the movement in Nepal are not professional leaders. In such a situation, this is also a good opportunity to increase mutual understanding.

During Balen Shah's visit to India, bilateral trade, climate change, air connectivity, tourism, energy and border disputes may also be discussed.

Importance of Balen Shah's visit to India

Image source, MEA

Union Minister Jitin Prasad welcomed Balen Shah at the airport. On Monday, Balen Shah will meet Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Draupadi Murmu.

There will be a meeting between the leaders of the two countries at Hyderabad House and after the formal meeting, some agreements are to be signed.

There is about 1750 km long border between India and Nepal, which is bordered by Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Sikkim and West Bengal.

There is a system of open borders in most of these parts. There is curiosity about this visit in both India and Nepal.

End

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

Ranjit Rai, former Indian Ambassador to Nepal, says, "The first thing that is important for India in this visit is that we should first understand the new leader, because we are not that familiar with him. However, there have been a lot of visits in the last seven-eight months. Rashtriya Swatantra Party (RSP) President Ravi Lamichhane came to India, then his Foreign Minister Shishir Khanal came to India. So the talks are going on. This is the first meeting of the two Prime Ministers, in this respect. This is very important."

Actually, since coming to power, Shah's policy had been that he was not meeting foreign leaders, but experts say that now the circumstances have changed.

Since the Iran war, Shah is facing many challenges due to rising fuel prices, lack of availability of fertilizers and sudden floods in Nepal's Bhotekoshi.

On this, former Nepalese Ambassador to India Shankar Sharma says that Shah was not going on foreign tours nor was talking much to foreign leaders.

He says that the officials of both the countries have done a lot of work on this visit.

He says, "However, at the domestic level too, such an environment was created that relations with other countries are very important for Nepal, especially a strong relationship with India is even more important. Anyway, messages are exchanged only when ambassadors and leaders of both the countries meet. Therefore, overall such an environment was created in Nepal too that Shah changed his mind."

air space issue

Image source: Getty Images

According to the news of Kathmandu Post, India has given positive signals to Nepal on the proposal of two billion dollar grant and line of credit. The final phase of talks are going on between the two countries on this issue.

According to the news, Nepal is demanding a grant and loan assistance package of $2 billion (about Rs 17,000 crore) from India as well as an additional air entry route from Indian airspace.

According to officials, India has shown a positive attitude on the proposal of economic assistance, but there is no consensus between the two countries on the issue of additional air routes.

On this, Shankar Sharma says, "Earlier also there was this line of credit, about 800 million dollars (worth Rs 7,400 crore), but it could not be fully utilized. Nepal wants this facility to be taken forward. A new financial package of two billion dollars should be given, which will include both grants and loans."

He says, “There has been a lot of damage due to the Bhotekoshi flood, so this will also be useful in reconstruction.” But this grant is not only related to floods, but is also related to other projects being built with India-Nepal collaboration."

Apart from this, there is also an issue of air space between the two countries, which is being discussed.

Actually, the main international airport of Nepal is in the capital Kathmandu. Apart from this, new airports have been built in Bhairahawa and Pokhara.

The objective of both is to increase connectivity within the country as well as to attract foreign tourists.

Nepal says that at present the air entry system for these airports is causing problems.

In fact, the number of entry points for international flights coming to Nepal through Indian airspace is very limited.

Therefore, some planes have to travel longer distances and their expenses also increase.

When we talked to Ranjit Rai about this, he said, "Actually, there is less operation of aircraft at these airports. There are few domestic flights and foreign flights are also less. Bhairahawa airport has been built with the loan of ADB (Asian Development Bank) and its contractor is also China. Whereas China has invested in Pokhara airport and it has also been constructed by a Chinese company."

He says, "To make both these airports successful and economically sustainable, permission is required from India because the aircraft flying to and from here will use Indian airspace."

Actually Bhairahawa falls in Rupandehi district of Nepal and this area is close to Uttar Pradesh.

Rupandehi also has Lumbini, the birthplace of Lord Buddha. At the same time, Pokhara is a famous tourist destination of Nepal.

Most international flights enter Nepal via the Simra route in south-central Nepal, even if their destination is in the western part of the country. This lengthens the flight path and puts additional pressure on air traffic.

He says, "If any plane takes off from these two airports, it will come into the Indian airspace and the plane that lands will also land through the Indian airspace. Allowing air space is a technical and security related issue. But if Nepal has built these airports by taking a loan and they are not operated properly, then they will become a burden for Nepal. This problem has to be solved by Nepal and it would be good if India can help in this. Some solution has to be found for it."

He explains, "But there is also a message here for Nepal that whenever such infrastructure projects are started in the future, there should be consultation. If you (Nepal) had talked to India beforehand and taken its consent, then this problem would not have arisen."

question of border dispute

The border dispute is an issue which is already being discussed between the two countries before this visit.

After assuming power in Nepal this year, a statement of Balen Shah was much discussed. Shah had said that both Nepal and India have encroached on each other's land.

However, after his statement, Nepal's Foreign Ministry had issued a clarification.

The ministry had said that the Prime Minister's statement was not in the context of any territorial claim, but was related to encroachment and use of land on the Nepal-India border.

Actually, in the year 2019, India had released its new political map.

In this map, Limpiyadhura, Kalapani and Lipulekh were shown as part of India.

After this, Nepal updated the political map of the country by amending the Constitution.

In the revised map, three strategically important areas – Lipulekh, Kalapani and Limpiyadhura – were shown within Nepal's border. India had called this step of Nepal unacceptable.

Now that Balen Shah is the Prime Minister of Nepal, fresh talks are being expected on the border dispute.

The question is whether his visit can lead to positive initiatives towards resolution of the border dispute?

Speaking to BBC News, Nepal's senior political analyst Kanak Mani Dixit had said, "I hope that this time the Prime Minister of Nepal will raise the issue of border dispute with Delhi. It may not be resolved immediately, but talks should start to solve this problem."

At the same time, former Nepalese Ambassador Shankar Sharma says, "A committee is working on cross-border holding and its aim is to complete this process in three years. But in the case of the dispute related to Susta, Lipulekh, Limpiyadhura and Kalapani, it was earlier decided that talks would be started under the Foreign Secretary level mechanism. It was also agreed upon, but no meeting was held after that."

Sharma says that this issue can be discussed in the Prime Minister level talks, but there is little possibility of it being mentioned in the joint statement.

However, there can be a discussion on this subject between the two Prime Ministers and some positive signal can be given from this.

Climate change is also an important issue

Image source, Leonardo MUNOZ / AFP via Getty Images

Apart from this, there is another issue and that is climate change.

Former Indian Ambassador to Nepal Ranjit Rai says that now climate change is also an important issue in the talks between the two countries.

Actually Balen Shah had given a speech in the United Nations General Assembly. In his speech, he had proposed to create a 'common arrangement to deal with the Himalayan climate crisis' under the leadership of India, China and Nepal.

He says, "I look at it this way, the issue of climate change, the issue of global warming, is rapidly affecting the Himalayas. The Himalayas are called the third pole, they are called water towers, two billion people are dependent on its water. So if due to global warming, glaciers will melt and rocks will break, then it will not only affect Nepal but many countries. It will affect China and it will also affect India.

He says, "The Bhotekoshi flood tells us that this issue of climate change is not just a multi-level issue, but it is also a bilateral issue and in this respect the climate issue is an important issue."

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

What does Nepal want from India, how much will Balen Shah be able to achieve?

Maharashtra: This tribal village, once deprived of electricity, water and roads, provided 11 doctors in ten years

After PM Modi's appeal, did people stop buying gold, what are experts saying?

must read

most popular