Image source: Facebook
Months after a massive military campaign targeting illegal gold prospectors in southern Egypt, a new initiative was put forward to legalize the activity of private gold prospectors, known as “al-dhaba,” by establishing a company that would regulate their work and grant them the necessary licenses.
However, the initiative, which was presented during a meeting in Cairo under the auspices of the head of the Egyptian Union of Tribes and Families, Ibrahim Al-Argany, raised questions about the nature of the union’s role and the entity that will manage the activity, in light of the presence of government institutions and companies already operating in the mining sector.
During the meeting, in which representatives and representatives of tribes from Aswan, Halayeb, Shalatin, and Marsa Alam participated, along with representatives of the security services and the “Egypt’s Future” agency affiliated with the Presidency of the Republic, a proposal was put forward to establish a company that would regulate the activity of private prospectors and grant them the necessary licenses.
The participants said that the initiative came as a “presidential directive,” and also included consideration of the release of those imprisoned in private excavation cases, with the exception of those accused of murder or drug trafficking. The proposed company will organize work in mining areas, monitor production, and integrate workers in the sector into the official system.
How will gold end its journey in 2026? What is behind his recent losses?
What do we know about the new Chinese gold?
Objections and questions about Al-Arjani's role
The announcement of the initiative sparked disagreement between supporters who see it as an opportunity to organize a sector that has been operating for decades, most of which operates outside the official framework, and opponents who believe that the management of a strategic resource the size of gold should remain in the hands of the relevant government institutions.
The Bani Hilal tribe, one of the tribes in southern Egypt, announced in a statement attributed to it its rejection of the outcomes of the meeting, considering that the management of the mineral resources file should be carried out through official state institutions in complete transparency, away from any tribal or social frameworks, and that benefiting from it or managing its file should not be limited to specific categories or groups.
Most read end
Stay updated with the latest current affairs
Download the app
BBC Arabic application for mobile phones
Al-Arjani, a businessman from North Sinai Governorate and one of the most prominent notables of the Tarabin tribe, does not hold any official position in the government.
Statements attributed to some Arab tribes in southern Egypt also appeared on social media platforms, in which they expressed their objection to the outcomes of the meeting and criticized the absence of their representatives, stressing that any initiative or position put forward in the name of the tribes must be based on broad consensus and fair representation, while rejecting the marginalization of any tribal component or the monopoly of speaking on behalf of all.
Arab and Bedouin tribes are spread in several regions of Egypt, especially in the Sinai Peninsula and the Eastern and Western Desert, and not all of them fall under the umbrella of the Union of Egyptian Tribes and Families, which is leading the initiative.
The union was established two years ago, and presents itself as an unifying framework for the tribes that aims to support the state’s efforts in development and enhance stability, especially in the border regions and Sinai, and is led by Sinai businessman Ibrahim Jumaa Al-Arjani.
Al-Arjani heads an economic group in his name that includes several companies, including the “Hala” tourism company, against which accusations were previously raised of receiving sums of money from those wishing to leave the Gaza Strip to Egypt via the Rafah crossing. These accusations were denied by the company and the Egyptian authorities, describing them as “unfounded.”
The parliamentary representative in Aswan, Hilal Al-Dandarawi, through his Facebook account, raised questions about the nature of the role that Al-Arjani plays in the file of gold exploration in the south of the country.
Tribal sources who spoke to the BBC also expressed their reservations about the absence of the Ministry of Petroleum from the meeting, and raised questions about the nature of Al-Arjani’s role, and whether it will be limited to mediation between the tribes and the state or will extend to other roles related to file management.
Parliamentarian Mustafa Bakri told the BBC that the meeting was an initial meeting with a limited number of tribal representatives to consult on the “presidential initiative” to regulate the mining sector, in preparation for a broader community dialogue with the people of Aswan and the Red Sea.
Bakri stressed that Al-Arjani’s role does not go beyond mediation to communicate with the tribes in his capacity as president of the federation.
Islam Al-Abadi, one of the representatives of the Ababda tribe who attended the meeting, agreed with this proposal, stressing that what happened was still within the framework of the initial understandings, saying that “everything that was proposed was the beginnings of an initiative whose details have not yet been completed,” adding: “We are not in favor of giving advance documents of support for any project before knowing its details.”
Speaking to the BBC, he indicated that other meetings will be held to complete the discussion regarding the regulations, implementation mechanisms, and revenue rates, pointing out that basic files are still under study, including the mechanism for purchasing and pricing gold, the state’s percentage of revenues, and the nature of the relationship between the proposed company, the Mineral Resources Authority, and the Shalatin Mineral Resources Company.
Bakri says that the “Egypt Future” agency will be the body supervising the implementation of the outcomes that will be agreed upon.
The “Egypt Future Agency for Sustainable Development” was established in 2022, after starting its practical activity in 2017, and it is a government entity that supervises a number of strategic projects for the state, especially in the fields of agriculture, food security and development.
Critics of the initiative believe that the establishment of a new company raises questions about the overlap of jurisdictions between it and existing entities, especially in light of the lack of clarity about the nature of the relationship between it and the Shalatin Company or the Mineral Resources Authority affiliated with the Ministry of Petroleum.
On the other hand, supporters of the initiative believe that its success may contribute to resolving a chronic crisis related to the presence of thousands of prospectors outside the official system, and provide the state with greater ability to monitor production and limit smuggling, while granting workers legal and security protection.
Parallel economy
Those working in private gold prospecting in southern Egypt are known as “dahaba,” and thousands of people in Aswan, the Red Sea, and the border areas depend on this activity as a main or seasonal source of income.
During the past years, a parallel economy has emerged linked to this activity, making it difficult for the state to track its production or subject it to complete control. It has also been linked to smuggling operations and security risks in desert areas.
Shalatin Mineral Resources Company, which was established in 2012, played a pivotal role in purchasing gold from prospectors and organizing activity in large areas of the Eastern Desert. It also expanded in establishing extraction and processing complexes, but a large segment of prospectors continued to work outside the official system.
Hassan Bakhit, former Undersecretary of the Ministry of Petroleum, believes that one of the reasons for the faltering efforts to legalize the activity is the existence of a gap between the economic conditions of prospectors and the official system, pointing to what he described as “excessive” imposition of fees and royalties, which may push some prospectors to cheat or work outside the official system.
Bakhit said that the declared percentages that the Shalatin Company receives from private prospectors amount to about 37 percent of the total production, while the director of one of the private mines says that the percentage may reach 40 percent, without deducting the expenses incurred by the miners, in addition to buying gold at prices lower than the market, which makes many prospectors avoid working within the official system.
According to the director of one of the private mines, who spoke to the BBC on condition of anonymity, many workers in the sector do not reject the idea of legalization, but they are demanding fair fees and rates, and that priority be given to people from border areas in job and investment opportunities related to mining.
Bakhit believes that the initiative "came at the right time", in light of the war in Sudan and the expansion of private mining and smuggling across the border areas, and what he described as "border skirmishes."
But he stressed the need for it to be followed by a clear legal framework that regulates the relationship between the state and prospectors and achieves a balance between the rights of both parties.
Security escalation against illegal exploration
This year witnessed an escalation in the face of random gold prospecting, as prison sentences were issued against hundreds of defendants in cases related to illegal mining.
The Egyptian Mining Law criminalizes illegal exploration for minerals, and violators are punished with imprisonment for a period of no less than one year and a fine ranging from 50,000 pounds (about 1,000 US dollars) to 5 million pounds (about 100,000 US dollars).
Last June, the armed forces launched what it called Operation “Southern Shield” to confront illegal exploration and smuggling in the eastern desert and southern border regions.
According to official data, the campaign resulted in the arrest of hundreds of Egyptians and foreigners, and thousands of people surrendered themselves to the armed forces, in one of the largest security campaigns targeting private mining activity in recent years.
Sudanese human rights organizations accused the Egyptian armed forces of killing dozens of Sudanese prospectors during the campaign, and said that some of the attacks occurred inside Sudanese territory, accusations that Egypt has repeatedly denied.
Great wealth and limited returns
These moves come as Egypt seeks to enhance the mining sector’s contribution to the economy, through legislative reforms that began in 2020, which included amending the Mineral Resources Law, implementing the royalties and taxes system, and issuing global tenders for exploration, with the aim of attracting more investments to the sector.
The government aims to attract annual investments amounting to one billion dollars in the mining sector, as part of a plan to increase its contribution to the gross domestic product.
Although Egypt owns more than 120 gold sites and mines in the Eastern Desert, the Red Sea, and Nubia, in addition to the “Golden Triangle” region, experts believe that the economic return from these wealth is still below the hoped-for levels, as a result of the slowness of exploration and development work, and the difficulty of receiving the allocated concession areas in light of the spread of illegal exploration activities.
The former Undersecretary of the Ministry of Petroleum believes that the success of the new initiative will remain dependent on the details that have not yet been announced.
Find out more
Short clips
End of short clips




