image copyrightBBC/Emmanuel Lafont

Although fecal microorganism transplantation is on the rise, only less than 3% of people are able to donate feces. Moreover, so-called ‘super poopers’ (highest quality stool donors) are much rarer. We have summarized the conditions for the most ideal stool donor.

One day in 2013, Adam Fay pondered what he should eat for dinner to ensure the best quality stool.

Fay, who was in her fourth year of medical school at the time, was learning how to treat Clostridioides difficile. This disease is a bacterial infection that causes serious illness in the stomach and intestines and is naturally resistant to many antibiotics. At the time, Fay knew of an elderly patient who needed a fecal microbiota transplant due to severe recurrent infections.

Fecal microbiota transplantation is a pioneering procedure in which another person's stool is injected into the patient's colon to transplant a healthy microbial community into the intestine. The goal is to suppress difficile bacteria and restore balance with the transplanted beneficial bacteria. But finding representation was a problem. In the past, there were not many stool banks, and family members and acquaintances of patients that Fay knew were either unable or reluctant to donate.

In the end, Fei came forward himself.

The night before the procedure, Fay chose a burrito for dinner. The next morning, he defecated in a pink medical basin in his student dormitory. Next, the stool was filtered through cotton gauze using saline solution and placed in a bottle. “I remember putting the bottles in paper bags because I had to carry them around with bottles of cloudy liquid,” he said.

A couple of hours later, Fay's stool was sprayed into the patient's intestines through a colonoscopy. Fay, now a gastroenterologist at New York University Langone Health, recalled that the procedure was successful. This is because the patient was not infected with difficile bacteria thereafter.

In recent years, there has been an explosion of research on the impact of the gut microbiome on health. In addition, interest in fecal transplantation, or fecal microbiota transplantation, has increased. Fecal microbiota transplantation has also been approved as a treatment for difficile. Clinical trials are also underway to determine whether it is effective for irritable bowel syndrome, diabetes, autism, and osteoporosis. Furthermore, there is growing interest in using it to treat cognitive decline and mental illness.

End of TOP News

Fecal transplantation is performed by directly injecting the patient's intestines or by orally administering feces processed into pill form. However, it is not easy to find someone with a representation that fits this purpose. The selection process is so rigorous that only some very healthy applicants are considered suitable. Additionally, top quality stool providers, commonly referred to as ‘super poopers’, are much more difficult to find.

To cover this story, I contacted six stool banks and research institutes to interview donors. But all were rejected. The reason was that it was so difficult to find a trustworthy donor that they could not risk the donor withdrawing due to an invasion of privacy. So who have the healthiest stools, and how do you find the most perfect stool?

stool donor

The stool donor selection process varies from institution to institution. This is because the standards vary depending on what disease it is used to treat. But the process is all very thorough.

“We use the same method of screening organ donors to vet candidates to find the healthiest people,” said Carl Crawford, a gastroenterologist at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York. This means that it undergoes thorough verification, just as it applies to people donating kidneys or blood.

To become a stool donor, you must first go through several surveys and interviews. Next, the patient undergoes a detailed blood and stool test to determine whether there is an infectious disease. There are over 30 types of test items for pathogens, parasites, multi-drug resistant bacteria, etc. Some hospitals even require COVID-19 and flu tests.

The reason the procedure is so difficult is because many infectious diseases can be transmitted through feces. In fact, there were cases of E. coli being accidentally transmitted during fecal microorganism transplantation. Some respiratory infectious diseases, including COVID-19, are also spread through fine particles spread into the air when flushing the toilet.

Donors are also checked for certain medical conditions, such as certain autoimmune diseases or mental health problems.

Some research institutes closely examine the medications and nutritional supplements taken by potential donors, including multivitamins and iron supplements. “We ask them thoroughly whether they are taking it and see if they can stop taking it,” said Susan Puttanen, a medical microbiologist at the University of Toronto. Additionally, check whether you have consumed foods that cause allergies in the past week. “Sometimes you just need a nut-free stool.”

Donors are usually between 18 and 48 years old. On the other hand, there is no age limit for patients receiving transplants. “I’ve treated a 17-year-old patient, and I’ve also treated a 96-year-old patient,” said Suzy Hota, an infectious disease specialist at the University of Toronto who performs fecal transplants.

Few places provide explicit standards for a donor's diet. But ideally, a diet rich in fiber and relatively healthy is good. Fruits, vegetables, and whole grains provide the right nutrients for your gut microbiome to thrive. “When you hear things like this, it might seem like the donor has to be a vegetarian, but in reality, people who eat a balanced diet have higher biodiversity in their gastrointestinal tracts,” Crawford said.

Horta and Puttanen said donors should be as thin as possible. There was a case in which a 32-year-old woman, who was previously slim, became obese after receiving a fecal transplant from a healthy but overweight donor. In addition, numerous factors are taken into consideration, from the amount of alcohol consumed to exercise and sleep habits. International travel is also strictly restricted to prevent donors from unintentionally becoming infected with antibiotic-resistant intestinal bacteria.

Crawford does not currently source stool for transplants directly. However, he said that in his experience, the rate of passing the initial screening process is about 3%. Among them, only about half are suitable for regular donation.

Toronto's Hota also reported that only about 1.6% of potential donors pass the initial screening. Of these, approximately 0.6% remain as regular donors.

image copyrightGetty Images

However, scientists who run stool banks and research programs point out that the practical and practical requirements that stool donors must meet should never be underestimated. Cases of a one-time donation for a patient who is an acquaintance, like Fei, are rare.

If you become one of the very few donors who passes the rigorous screening process, you will likely be offered participation in a regular toilet program. If that happens, you may have to visit the research center almost every day and defecate in the designated donor-only restroom.

Many stool banks pay kickbacks to donors. For example, in the United States, compensation per donation ranges from $25 to $100. It is more efficient to utilize existing personnel rather than finding new donors every time. For this reason, each stool bank receives repeated donations from verified donors.

Hota explained that trust must be built while respecting the donor's autonomy. This is because researchers often ask donors to tell them about even the smallest changes in their daily lifestyle.

Superlative Fecal Donor

Nevertheless, what can be predicted through such initial screening and testing alone is limited.

Any stool from a qualified donor has the same chance of curing a recurrent D. difficile infection. However, for certain diseases, research has shown that stool from some special donors has a much higher remission rate (the rate at which symptoms are alleviated or disappear) than other donors.

For example, a 2015 study tested fecal transplants in patients with ulcerative colitis, a type of inflammatory bowel disease. At that time, only 9 out of 38 patients achieved remission. However, 7 of these 9 patients received fecal transplants from the same donor.

Another study conducted in 2017 used transplantation using a mixture of feces from up to seven donors. As a result, patients who received a mixture of feces from one specific donor were about twice as likely to improve than those who did not. However, it was not clear why this ‘top-quality’ stool was so effective.

It is not common to perform full gut microbiome testing during the stool donation process. However, according to research, super puffers are not only quantitatively rich in intestinal bacteria, but also have a wide variety of types. Additionally, feces often contain species known as beneficial bacteria, such as 'Picalibacterium prosnich'. This fungus produces butyrate, a fatty acid that performs several beneficial functions, including reducing inflammation and protecting the intestinal lining.

Of course, a specific person's stool cannot be a panacea. Feces from donors that are ideal for treating difficile may not have any effect in patients with irritable bowel syndrome or depression, Fay said. “We’re still trying to figure out that ‘secret combination.’”

“I am convinced that ‘super puffers’ exist,” Homan said. However, he said that because there is still no reliable definition of the 'best stool', there is no testing method yet available to find it.

Meanwhile, some studies say that matching a patient with a compatible donor is more important than finding the perfect stool. In this regard, academic circles expect that it will be possible to match donors and patients based on the diversity of intestinal microorganisms.

From feces to pills

Even if the highest quality feces from ‘super poopers’ are used, fecal transplantation is still far from the realm of an exact science.

“My biggest concern is probably the unpredictability of fecal microbiota transplantation,” said Sarah Venterchia of Queen Mary University of London. “Because you’re transplanting an entire microbial community, there are a lot of variables to consider.” This means that if the donor, processing method, or recipient changes, the pattern of microbial changes can also vary significantly.

On the other hand, Crawford said fecal transplants could be a stepping stone to creating a standard treatment. For example, 'Ferring Pharmaceuticals' produces enemas made from donor stool, which is rich in beneficial bacteria. Ceres Therapeutics also manufactures oral pills containing specific bacterial spores extracted from human feces. Both products have been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration as a treatment for recurrent difficile infections.

Crawford said that in the future, there is a high possibility of developing a method of obtaining microorganisms from donors that are highly effective in treating difficile infections, cultivating them in large quantities in a laboratory, and then taking them in pill form. He added, “I believe that microbiome-based treatments have the potential to become the mainstay of future medicine.”

But as Crawford envisions the future of utilizing microbial communities, there is also a sense of anxiety at the back of his mind. This is because modern people’s lifestyles are damaging the human body’s natural microbial community. For example, ultra-processed foods are known to reduce the diversity of the intestinal microbial community.

“I worry that we are losing the uniqueness of many of the microorganisms in our gastrointestinal tract that can help us fight the next disease that comes our way,” Crawford said. He compared the potential healing properties of the gut environment to the many useful plant-based chemicals found in tropical rainforests. “We take it for granted, but our gut microbiome is much larger than the rainforest. It can be of great help to us.”

*This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for the diagnosis of a medical professional.

Learn more

Is expensive, high-strength cold medicine better? Comparing prices and ingredients

'I couldn't even tell my best friend'... Aftereffects of childbirth that last a lifetime

Foreign prescription obesity treatment drugs allowed to be brought in... Will the ‘Maunjaro Expedition’ be okay?

‘4 hours of sleep a day is enough.’ Am I really a person who can do that?

How to increase exercise without spending any time

'It wasn't until I collapsed at work that I realized I was deficient in vitamin D.'

video

Video, 'Nobody was punished' for alleged gang rape at Cornell University, broadcast length 1,34

Video, 'Irreversible water temperature' How hot have the seas of Ulleungdo and Dokdo become, broadcast length 5,34

Video, North Korean defector women talk about dating and sex in North Korea, broadcast length 3,59

Video, from before to after the 'K-pop craze'...the path taken by female musicians, broadcast length 12,14

top news

‘The highest peak of human health’... The secret of a super potty worker with healthy stools

Poland: 'Russian missile invades airspace'... The moment of the explosion was captured on CCTV.

The International Court of Justice recognizes Myanmar as responsible for the Rohingya genocide... What does this landmark ruling mean?

this time issue

Most viewed news