photo copyrightElena Hoicka
Drawings appeared on the wall, cookies mysteriously disappeared from the jar, and the child, standing with a crayon in his hand or covered in crumbs, blames it all on a dog or a ghost. Most parents have experienced a child trying to deceive or mislead them. But this is an important part of children's mental development.
This is a shortened and adapted translation of material from a BBC correspondent. The original in English can be read here.
"It's really a skill that a child develops and hones through play," says clinical psychologist Dr Jade Redfern on the BBC parenting podcast CBeebies Parenting.
Experts explain why it's healthy behavior when a child starts trying to cheat, and share tips for encouraging honesty.
End of Subscribe to our social networks and newsletters
Young children are not yet sophisticated enough to lie fully, but they are quite capable of trying before they are a year old, Redfern said.
One of the studies mentioned in the podcast, from researchers at the University of Bristol, notes that around a quarter of children begin to learn some form of deception by 10 months.
Professor Elena Hoyka, who led this study, admits that it is amazing how dexterous and cunning children can be at such an early age - including her own.
“As a mother of three, I can attest to how skilled and resourceful they can be. For example, they often hide under the table or in the bathroom to secretly eat sweets or chocolate,” says Hojka.
End of Most Popular
According to the researcher, the deception that two-year-old children resort to is usually quite primitive: they can pretend not to hear their parents or deny that they have done something.
“They may also secretly do something forbidden: for example, look into a bag they were told not to go into when they think no one is looking. Or come up with excuses - say that they need to go to the toilet when they are asked to clean up after themselves,” says the researcher.
By the age of three, children become more creative and better understand how language and other people's thinking works.
In addition, according to Hoyka, children begin to intentionally hide some information. For example, they may honestly tell their parents that their brother or sister hit them, but at the same time keep silent about the fact that they themselves hit the brother or sister first.
Such attempts to mislead are a sign of the development of what Redfern calls “theory of mind.”
This extension will help if you have difficulties accessing the BBC Russian Service website.
Download extension
End of story Chrome browser extension - link
“As children grow older, they need to realize that they are their own individuals with their own minds and their own intentions,” she explains. “This helps them develop empathy skills—the ability to think about another person’s thoughts and feelings that may be different from their own.”
There is also a lie out of self-preservation: the child does not want to upset or upset the parent.
“All human beings are motivated by affection,” says Redfern. “Children are driven by the need to maintain relationships with those who care about them, because they are completely dependent on them.”
Children begin to recognize quite early on what brings them closer to significant adults and what distances them from them, Redfern says. With that in mind, she says honesty can be encouraged by creating a safe environment where the child is not afraid to tell the truth.
“We need to find ways to help children feel safe enough that they can tell the truth, even if they have made a mistake and are afraid of upsetting us.”
This is what Rachel Duffy, winner of the latest series of The Traitors, told the CBeebies Parenting podcast that she strives for with her children.
Rachel, a mother of three, recalls the time her eldest son borrowed his brother's bicycle and broke it when he crashed into a car. At first he tried to lie.
"I told him, 'You won't get in big trouble if you tell me the truth.' I just walked away and gave him some space to think. And he said: “Yes, it was me.” He realized that this was a safe space. We talked - not in a raised voice, without roaring, without shouting.”
According to Redfern, this is a good example of how to deal with such situations. Sometimes, she adds, there are times when a lie or slight omission is appropriate: for example, if someone received a gift they didn't want, or when describing other people's appearance.
“My kids recently told me with delightful spontaneity that I’m very wrinkled,” she says. “Again, I try to approach it with openness and curiosity.”
She said they talked about why they thought she was wrinkled.
“I think as children get older, having these types of open conversations and expressions of curiosity really helps develop empathy for other people's feelings when they are shown and modeled for it,” she says.
Download the new BBC World Service app!
When you first open the app, select "BBC News Russian Service" and receive notifications about important news, analysis, videos and podcasts.
Important: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
Find out more
Video playlist
End Video playlist




