Image source: Sajjad HUSSAIN / AFP via Getty Images

Rahul Gandhi described India's economy in America as an 'economic disaster'. He mentioned the problems of unemployment, weakening industries and education system.

After this he repeated his allegations on the electoral process and said that India's role in world affairs has weakened.

After this political controversy started in India. BJP accused Rahul Gandhi of damaging India's image and the credibility of its democratic institutions from foreign soil.

Congress replied that the government is more worried about the state of the economy than the fact that Rahul Gandhi is speaking on these issues and the world is listening to him.

But behind these allegations and counter-allegations, a question comes up again and again, why does Rahul Gandhi raise controversial issues related to India on international forums?

Is this a well thought out strategy? Does the discussion he gets abroad give him any benefit in Indian politics?

What did Rahul Gandhi say in America?

On November 17, Rahul Gandhi spoke to students and teachers at Columbia University in New York. The discussion was moderated by The New York Times journalist Lydia Polgreen.

During this, Rahul Gandhi said, "The clear thing is that India is in a state of economic disaster. This is the truth. The media also ignores it. But there is a huge problem of unemployment in India and there are serious problems in the education system too."

End

Rahul Gandhi claimed that small and medium businesses and agriculture are the backbone of the Indian economy, but this backbone has been broken. He also criticized the Central Government's schemes like 'Make in India' and 'Start-up India'.

In the same conversation, he also reiterated his allegations of irregularities in the electoral process. Here, BJP responded to Rahul Gandhi's economic claims.

BJP President Nitin Nabin said that institutions like World Bank and IMF (International Monetary Fund) consider India as a fast growing economy.

BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari, while mentioning 7.8 percent economic growth in the first quarter of 2026-27, questioned Rahul Gandhi's statement of 'economic disaster'.

Does Rahul Gandhi deliberately create controversy?

Image source: Ritesh Shukla/Getty Images

Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava

Learn more

In a conversation with Dushyant Kumar for BBC News Hindi, senior journalist Sharad Gupta said that he does not believe that Rahul Gandhi goes abroad and makes controversial statements as per any fixed strategy.

He says, "There are many people who cannot control themselves while speaking. Rahul Gandhi is one of them. But whatever he says, he speaks from his heart. He believes in what he says. It is not that he speaks to create a controversy. He only says what he thinks is right. But whatever he says, a controversy arises."

According to Sharad Gupta, Rahul Gandhi expresses his views and after that a political controversy starts.

The same thing happened after the statements given in New York.

BJP spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia termed Rahul Gandhi's allegations as wrong and baseless. He alleged that Rahul Gandhi tries to weaken India's international image through his foreign tours.

Pawan Kheda, head of the media and publicity department of Congress, replied to this.

He said that the government is not worried about the situation of the economy and inflation. His problem is that Rahul Gandhi is speaking on these issues and the world is listening to him.

What did you say about the elections in Chicago?

Rahul Gandhi reached University of Chicago on 18 November. Here he had a conversation with Professor Robert Pape.

The main topic of the program was Iran war and India's role in the world. But during the question-and-answer session, the conversation reached India's elections.

Rahul Gandhi was asked that if the opposition has so much doubt on the electoral process, then why does it contest elections?

He said that if the opposition stops contesting elections, it will damage the democratic structure of India. Rahul Gandhi also mentioned the 2014 Lok Sabha elections. He said that he could not understand some of the differences between victory and defeat in that election and that was when he felt that something had gone wrong.

But he also admitted that he had no evidence at that time, so he could not say anything publicly.

Rahul Gandhi claimed that he later found evidence and showed it to Congress leaders. According to him, party leaders asked him not to make it public.

After this statement, Union Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju hit back at Rahul Gandhi.

He said that Rahul Gandhi criticizes the government and the Prime Minister in India and the opposition also protests. If there was no democratic freedom in the country, how could all this have happened?

Is speaking abroad part of the strategy?

Image source, Ishant Chauhan/Hindustan Times via Getty Images

BJP's reaction to Rahul Gandhi's foreign tours is nothing new. After his statements, the question arises again and again whether choosing such platforms is a part of his political strategy.

Sharad Gupta says that one advantage of going to a foreign stage can be that a leader's international identity is created.

He says, "What is seen, sells. If you want to make your mark at the international level, you go to international platforms."

Sharad Gupta gives the example of former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee.

According to him, Vajpayee also used to visit international forums before becoming the Prime Minister and this made him known outside India also.

Sharad Gupta says that foreign platforms give an opportunity to a leader to present his views in front of the international audience and create his own identity. But does this also benefit Indian politics?

Sharad Gupta says, "It does not seem that this will be of much benefit in domestic politics."

According to Sharad Gupta, Rahul Gandhi has been complaining that when he speaks publicly in India, the media does not give enough space to his words. Rahul Gandhi has also been saying that his voice is suppressed in the Parliament and he does not get an opportunity to present his views fully.

Sharad Gupta says, "Maybe they feel that their voice will reach here through foreign platforms."

Rahul Gandhi also said something similar in his Chicago conversation.

He said that they get permission to visit foreign universities like Chicago, Columbia and Harvard, but in India, they do not get the opportunity of such interaction in institutions like Delhi University.

Senior journalist Saba Naqvi had a long discussion about Rahul Gandhi speaking on foreign forums in BBC News Hindi program 'Dinbhar'.

She says that it is difficult to understand why Rahul Gandhi goes to international forums and says such things about India, on which politics later starts in the country.

Saba Naqvi connects this to Rahul Gandhi's interest in long discussions.

"I feel like it's his hobby," she says.

According to him, the kind of discussion that Rahul Gandhi had with an American journalist at Columbia University can be held with independent journalists in India too.

Saba Naqvi believes that perhaps no central university of India would invite Rahul Gandhi to give such a platform. But the Congress party itself can organize such programs in different parts of the country.

In these programs, Rahul Gandhi can raise issues like economy, employment, education, elections and democracy directly among the people whose lives are affected by them.

BJP's allegations

BJP alleges that Rahul Gandhi tarnishes the image of India by going abroad. Sharad Gupta does not agree with this argument.

He says that now anything said in India does not remain within the borders of the country. Whatever a leader says in Parliament, rally or press conference also reaches the world.

Sharad Gupta says, "Rahul Gandhi is repeatedly accused of tarnishing the image of the country by going abroad. This is not right. Because whatever he says here will also go abroad."

According to him, the world keeps an eye on India's issues and now it is not easy to divide the audience into domestic and foreign segments.

He says, "Now there is a global audience. Whether you speak here in Parliament or anywhere in the country, the message will reach abroad."

Sharad Gupta says that if Rahul Gandhi is asked a question about India abroad, he cannot be expected not to answer merely because of space.

He says, "If he is asked any question on foreign soil, he will not say that the question was not asked on the country's soil, hence he will not answer."

Should the leader of the opposition speak more within the country?

Image source: AFP via Getty Images

Saba Naqvi believes that Rahul Gandhi has every right to express his views on any platform. But since he holds an important parliamentary position like Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, he should talk more within the country on issues related to India.

In his opinion, Congress should create such platforms in different parts of the country, where Rahul Gandhi can have long conversations with independent journalists and common people.

Saba Naqvi does not think that Rahul Gandhi gets any special benefit in domestic politics by going abroad and speaking on India's economy, jobs and elections.

He and Sharad Gupta have almost the same opinion on this issue.

Sharad Gupta believes that foreign platforms can help in building the international identity of a leader. But it is not necessary that this will be of great benefit to Indian politics.

Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.

Download the new BBC World Service app

Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place

Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.

short video

end of short video

top story

Controversy over Rahul Gandhi's statements in America, what benefit does he get from speaking abroad?

Sexual abuse at McDonald's: 'They waited for little girls to turn 18'

Mufti, Maulana and now AI: Whom should Muslims trust on questions of religion?

must read

most popular