image copyrightReuters
"Aren't you also a Chinese spy?" - This is a joke that keeps appearing on social media these days.
Nvidia (Huida; Nvidia) founder Huang Jensen was involved in an extramarital affair. The Chinese woman Alice Huang who had a relationship with him was accused of working for the Chinese intelligence agency. A large number of jokes connecting Asian women with "Chinese spies" and "honey traps" quickly emerged on the Internet.
These seemingly innocuous memes about current events are troubling to some Asian women.
"It sounds like I am saying that although I speak very proficient English, have a master's degree from a top university in the United States, and have a decent full-time job, these must have some unknown intentions and are not the result of my own efforts and intelligence." Ms. Yu, an Asian woman who has lived in the United States for nearly ten years, told BBC Chinese.
She said that such jokes have been going on since she moved to the United States, and even after she married a local white man, her father-in-law would tease her like this. She worries that recent public opinion has reinforced these stereotypes, which will further affect opportunities in the workplace.
Some Asian women interviewed said that they have been "sexualized" for a long time in Western society, which directly threatens their personal safety.
Steering the line between humor and bigotry, what worries do these women have? How to regain the right to speak?
‘Chinese spy’ memes emerge
After the revelation of Jen-Hsun Huang's extramarital affair, online discussions quickly extended from personal relationships and chip safety issues to the gender and ethnic imagination of Asians.
End of Hot Reading
In an Instagram video, a white man pointed to four pictures on the screen: the founders of technology giants Meta, Coinbase, Oracle, Nvidia and their Asian partners.
He told the camera: "Obviously, there are some commonalities among people in the technology industry. I also work in the technology industry." Then he turned to the Asian wife next to him and asked, "Are you sure you are Vietnamese?" The Asian wife in the video nodded and responded "yea".
The short video, released on November 13, received 1.7 million likes, 1.2 million retweets and more than 30,000 comments. Many people commented and joked, "Is this the reason why you can succeed in the technology industry? Because you have an Asian wife?", "You will become a billionaire soon", or "yea is a typical Chinese spy's reply", "she may be an AI Silicon Valley robot".
These jokes also happen in real life.
Ms. Qiao, who has worked for a large investment bank in the City of London for nearly ten years, told BBC Chinese that when she was chatting with her colleagues in the office recently, she was jokingly asked by the other party: "Aren't you also a Chinese spy?"
Ms. Shen, who now lives in Berlin, Germany, and works for an international non-governmental organization, also said that because she is a Korean in China, her colleagues teased her whether she was a "Chinese spy or a North Korean spy."
She said that this kind of joke had been going on for many years before the scandal of Huang Jen-Hsun's extramarital affair was exposed. One year, a friend's birthday greeting to her was "Happy birthday spy girl." She was unhappy with these remarks.
The potential dangers of "fetish complex"
The phenomenon of "female" implies that white tech tycoons are prone to fall into the "honey trap" trap cast by Chinese-American women.
Ms. Ai, who works in the IT industry in London, told BBC Chinese that in the past week she has been constantly seeing AI-generated intimate images of older white men and young Asian women together. Some of the captions read "China's doing honeypot 9/11 right now."
She said that she "immediately felt uncomfortable" after seeing these pictures. She expressed her feelings to her friends, but the other party joked: "Whether the AI industry is destroyed or not, Huang (Jen-Hsun) can at least have multiple lovers."
Chen Yining, a professor at the School of Communication at National Chengchi University in Taiwan, analyzed that Asian women are often fetishized in the West, which means that their attraction mainly comes from the imagination of the entire ethnic group, rather than the specific person in front of them. “When a person is liked because she is perceived as submissive, mysterious, or exotic, she is reduced to a fungible category.”
As for the racialized image of Asian women constructed in Western cultural imagination, she said that it is called orientalization in academic research. From the United States restricting the entry of Chinese women based on the image of prostitutes in the 19th century, to "Madama Butterfly" and the sex industry in Asia during the war, Western culture has gradually formed two contradictory stereotypes: as docile and obedient as a "lotus flower", or as beautiful and dangerous as a "Dragon Lady".
Asian women are highly "sexualized" in the West, which may have dangerous consequences.
An article published by the French think tank The Gender in Geopolitics Institute in 2023 pointed out that the value of Asian women is easily reduced to appearance and sexual attractiveness rather than personal abilities and achievements, increasing their risk of sexual harassment and sexual violence. A 2021 report released by Stop AAPI Hate and the National Asian Pacific Islander Women's Forum (NAPAWF) shows that 52.6% of East Asian women living in the United States have been verbally harassed, and 9.2% have been physically harassed.
Ms. Guo, who works in an entertainment company in London, said that the recent controversy caused by the Jen-Hsun Huang incident will only make the situation of Asian women worse. "The stereotype is deeper. I feel very bad about this matter and also very worried."
Double Dilemma: "Glass Ceiling" and "Bamboo Ceiling"
This recent wave of memes reflects the workplace prejudice that Asian women have long faced in Europe and the United States.
May, who works in the City of London, said that this kind of teasing has been happening since she started working, and colleagues at all levels will say it. In the workplace, it is often difficult to clearly point out the inappropriateness of such jokes that are not directly discriminatory on gender or ethnicity, which makes her feel helpless.
Joyce (pseudonym), an Asian woman who also works in London, believes that Asian women themselves are very sexualized in the technology and financial industries, and are treated as symbolic tools and not respected. "Now these people (who have the right to speak) have even found a reason."
This situation is related to the ongoing gender imbalance in technology and finance.
On the financial recruitment and industry platform efinancialcommerce, Ms. Tang, an Asian woman working in investment banking, shared that these two industries are still dominated by men globally, and women have limited representation in core decision-making positions. She observed that some teams have only one or two women among 15 people. In this kind of work environment, women in the minority often need to be more careful to maintain their professional positions, and sometimes they may not be able to establish mutually supportive relationships with other women.
Dr. Yanran Yao, a lecturer in Chinese politics and society at King's College London, pointed out that Asian women in Western workplaces not only face the "glass ceiling", which is the obstacle to advancement that women face in male-dominated industries, but may also encounter the "bamboo ceiling" (bamboo ceiling), which is the special prejudice against Asian identity, forming a double obstacle.
"In fact, many Chinese and Asian women have achieved high achievements in the world and have a high economic status, but this does not translate into political trust. As a result, when Asian women are stigmatized, many people will not have a lot of sympathy and support."
Professor Chen Yining added that "honey traps" and "spy mistresses" are widely circulated on the Internet. Even if the accusations themselves are yet to be investigated, the costs of such narratives are often borne by ordinary Asian women: they are suspected of being loyal in the workplace, labeled as having ulterior motives in social and intimate relationships, and even face harassment and violence.
"Huang Jensen himself has admitted to being unfaithful in his marriage, but the online discussion surrounding the incident has largely focused on the identity, appearance and so-called allure of the female party. This is a classic example of the intersection of racial stereotypes and misogynistic culture."
End of content
How to distinguish between the Chinese government, Chinese citizens, and Asians?
The protagonist in this incident, Huang Le, is a former executive of Singapore-based Megaspeed. The company is suspected of purchasing a large amount of Huida's high-end chips and then exporting them to China, thereby evading the US export ban on China. She is accused of working for Chinese intelligence agencies, and both the FBI and Huida have launched investigations into this.
Previously, the Chinese government promulgated the National Intelligence Law in 2017. Article 7 stipulates that "any organization and citizen shall support, assist and cooperate with national intelligence work in accordance with the law, and keep the secrets of national intelligence work that they know." The Wall Street Journal also recently published an article stating that China is deploying the world's largest intelligence collection operation and that American technology and academia have been infiltrated.
In this Huang Renxun incident, how the media reports on national security issues has come under scrutiny.
On November 11, the Asian American Journalists Association (AAJA) issued a statement stating that investigating espionage accusations is legitimate and important journalistic work, but the media should clearly distinguish between the Chinese government, Chinese citizens and Asian Americans, and cannot infer a person's political stance and loyalties based on his ethnic background or nationality.
The association named and criticized some media reports that use Asian surnames to create puns and headline gimmicks that may strengthen the connection between Asian identity and espionage activities, including the headline "Two Huangs don't make a right" published by The Economist on November 9, and the front-page headline "HUANG HUANG BANG BANG" used by the New York Post on the same day.
The former title originates from the English proverb "Two wrongs don't make a right", while bang means sexual behavior in English slang and is a more vulgar term.
Professor Chen Yining said that Huang is a very common surname among Chinese people, and the two parties involved are not related. "Using surnames to create puns may seem humorous, but in fact it turns the name of an ethnic group into a symbol of laughter and suspicion, and those who bear the consequences are many ordinary people with the same surname and ethnicity."
Dr. Yao Yanran from King's College London pointed out that even if China's National Intelligence Law makes the outside world wary, the laws of any country should not become suspicious of a country's citizens, otherwise it will put overseas Chinese in trouble.
"On the one hand, overseas Chinese are not trusted by the Chinese government, and they are afraid that their words and deeds will arouse the Chinese government's vigilance. On the other hand, the countries where they live do not trust them either, resulting in an increasingly voiceless state."
Yao Yanran believes that whether it is because of a democratic society or the most basic human rights, "since overseas Chinese have come to a new country and become students or company employees, (this country) has the responsibility to protect them."
image copyrightAFP
Identity within Asian women
In addition to linking Asian identity to espionage activities, some reports and online discussions have also blurred the boundaries between different countries and regions in Asia, triggering identity disputes.
Professor Chen Yining pointed out, "Huang Renxun was born in Taiwan, and Huang Le is Chinese. If Taiwanese, Chinese, Chinese citizens and the Chinese government are confused, not only will the facts be inaccurate, but it will also strengthen the framework of 'Asians are all suspicious'."
In some comments on Threads, some non-Chinese Asian women emphasized their nationality and identity to avoid being mistaken for Chinese. At the same time, there are also Chinese netizens who are dissatisfied with some netizens from Taiwan, Hong Kong or Singapore who deliberately emphasize the difference from mainland China, believing that there is some sense of status superiority involved.
Some Asian netizens uploaded photos. They held up their Singaporean, Malaysian and other Asian passports, emphasizing that they were not Chinese nationals, smiling and taking selfies with the caption "I am not a Chinese spy."
Dr. Yao Yanran pointed out that in recent years, Asian women have increasingly been in a state of confrontation. "During the COVID-19 epidemic, they had to fight against the stigma of the (Wuhan) virus, and now they have to fight against the stigma of (Chinese) beautiful spies. This has also led to divisions within the Asian community."
"What causes Asian women to always be in such a defensive state?"
Use humor to regain the right to speak?
However, in the recent wave of online discussions, not all Asian women feel offended, and some have joined the meme craze.
Someone put together various sexy photos of themselves with the caption "What Jensen Huang saw before Nvidia goes down."
Rachel Yu, a comedy blogger from China and based in New York, also posted a series of humorous short videos on Instagram, satirizing the phenomenon of public opinion portraying Huang as a "victim." In one of the short videos with more than 5 million views, she played the role of a "Chinese beauty spy" in Chinatown, wearing a pink cheongsam to seduce "Huang Renxun". When questioned whether she was a spy, she denied it and the other party agreed without hesitation.
In another short video with more than 2 million views, she played the role of "Huang Jen-Hsun's mistress" and apologized in a joking tone: "I slept with a married billionaire. I take responsibility, but I didn't do it for China, I did it for myself." She asked, "Can't a Chinese woman be an ordinary mistress? I don't need a man in Beijing to tell me what to do, I know how to do it."
Someone left a message under the video, criticizing it as "eating steamed buns with human blood, with no regard for the lives of other Asian women." They believed that such jokes were tantamount to self-dwarfing. However, some people found the humor funny and left a message saying, "Be the best mistress and don't let China take away your credit." Some people also believe that the Chinese women involved in media reports have almost no subjectivity. This type of ironic film is to re-highlight women's own voices and choices.
Scholar Yao Yanran pointed out that in the pervasive racial and gender stereotypes, everyone has their own way of resisting prejudice. Sometimes some self-mockery or active exaggerated imitation is also an anti-stigmatization action.
"Taking back the right to speak through humor is sometimes very useful for some women, because she regains control of the narrative about her own image."
Explore more
More short films
More short films end




