Image source, ANI
Pakistan's Climate Change Minister Musadiq Malik has come to India to participate in the first 'Dialogue of Civilizations' of Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO).
'Dialogue of Civilizations' is being held in New Delhi from 20 to 22 November 2026.
This is the visit of a minister of Pakistan government to India after three years. Earlier in the year 2023, the then Foreign Minister of Pakistan Bilawal Bhutto had come to India to participate in the meeting of SCO Foreign Ministers.
There is a lot of discussion in Pakistan about the opposition of India's opposition party Congress regarding his visit, Malik's travel plans and his speech given in SCO.
While the arrival of a Pakistani minister in the SCO meeting is once again being seen as an improvement in the relations between the two countries, this visit was also not free from controversies.
In fact, after the Pahalgam attack on 22 April 2022, tension between the two countries had increased significantly. India launched 'Operation Vermillion' after this attack, after which a brief military conflict started between the two countries.
India repeatedly accuses Pakistan of supporting and helping extremist activities and anti-India organizations. However, Pakistan has been continuously denying this.
When Musaddiq Malik came to India, he also had to face these questions and he said that his country too was 'suffering from terrorism'.
End
But the speech of Musadiq Malik is being discussed the most and it has been published prominently in the media of Pakistan.
Mention of Ghalib and Humayun
Image source, @Team_Musadik
Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava
Learn more
Pakistan's leading newspaper Dawn gave special space to Musaddiq Malik's mention of Ghalib in Delhi.
Malik said he initially wanted to deliver his speech in English, the newspaper reported, "but he found it strange to speak in English, a stone's throw from the tombs of Mirza Ghalib and Sufi saint Nizamuddin."
Actually Malik had mentioned this in the beginning of his speech.
He said, "Ghalib's grandfather came from Samarkand. Ghalib considered himself a great Persian poet, but today he is known all over the world because of Urdu."
Don has shared the video of Musaddiq Malik in which he is saying, "Delhi said that 'there are other Sukhnavars in the world who are very good, they say that Ghalib's style is better than others.' This is the spirit but I have come before you. There are many voices here. There are many speakers. Today we have all come here with our own voices."
The SCO meeting was organized in the Old Fort of Delhi. Referring to this fort, Malik described it as a complete document of history in itself.
He said that 'Mughal emperor Humayun, who came from Central Asia, had laid its foundation.'
He also talked about the historical importance of the fort. He told that both Humayun and his rival Sher Shah Suri, despite being opponents of each other, became a part of the history of this fort.
Talking about Pakistan's historical ties with other regions, Malik said the country's historical ties extend to Bukhara and Samarkand in the north, while its cultural ties reach to Persia and Arabia in the west.
Dawn gave prominent place to Musaddiq Malik's mention of Nepal's floods and other environmental issues.
Musaddiq Malik on Saturday described climate change as a big threat to civilization and historical heritage.
'Pakistan also suffers from extremism'
However, some people in Pakistan viewed Malik's visit with apprehension.
Pakistan's leading newspaper The Express Tribune published an opinion piece in which journalist Fahad Hussain wrote, "Indians had no chance. They thought Malik would be badly cornered in their city. But on the contrary, he became the center of discussion among the people there."
He wrote, "Dr. Mussadiq's visit has created a stir in the Indian media. TV anchors and reporters are in a tizzy. It is also gratifying. Dr. Mussadiq has done exactly what was needed in India and with Indians. He maintained utmost decency despite making unnecessarily provocative statements."
While talking to journalists on Saturday, Musadiq Malik was asked why action is not taken "against the terrorists present in Pakistan?"
In response to this, he said that he has come to a multilateral platform and wants that the talks on this platform should proceed in a good and orderly manner.
During a conversation with journalists, he said, "Whenever there is talk on terrorism, there will be transparency in it. Evidence will have to be presented from both the sides. Pakistan has also had to face a lot of pain and suffering due to terrorism."
According to Fahad Hussain, for those people of Pakistan who are hopeful that relations between the two neighboring countries can and should be normalized, this visit is a reminder of how ridiculous their dream is. India has changed, but not in a better direction."
Urdu News also prominently published Malik's statement on extremism.
According to the news, "Malik has said that instead of blaming each other on the issue of terrorism, there is a need to adopt a transparent approach and move forward on the basis of evidence. In the last one and a half to two years, thousands of people have lost their lives in terrorist incidents in Pakistan and we have to bear funerals every day."
"He said that countries affected by terrorism will do whatever they deem necessary to protect their children. But for the security of the region, it is very important to discuss this issue seriously and with dignity."
'We will take you to Mohenjodaro and Harappa'
Image source: AFP via Getty Images
During his keynote address, Mussadiq Malik invited the delegates to visit Pakistan.
A post on his
On the sidelines of the forum, Dr. Malik also had an informal meeting with India's Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat at the historic Old Fort of Delhi. During this, there was a long conversation between the two ministers.
Geo News has given space to that part of Musaddiq Malik's speech in which climate change has been described as a threat to civilization.
According to the news, when asked about the civilizational relations between India and Pakistan, he said, "I believe that dialogue happens between parties having different identities. Consistency does not require communication. There is only monologue in unison. "Dialogue is about diversity."
"I believe that if you go to archaeological excavation sites between India, Pakistan, Russia, China and Central Asian countries, you will find a glimpse of dialogue at the forefront. I think this is a very welcome dialogue."
"During the meeting in Delhi, the Climate Change Minister stressed the need for more dialogue under the SCO platform."
"We are having a dialogue between different civilizations and cultures. I believe there should be more such events. Dialogue between civilizations is especially important at a time when the entire region is going through a transition and geopolitical situations are changing rapidly. This is a very welcome initiative."
What was published on the protest against Malik's visit
Image source: NurPhoto via Getty Images
Geo News has published news about Malik's visit to Delhi.
Geo News has mentioned Malik's statement in which he said that 'Pakistan will support all efforts to promote peace and stability in the region. And Islamabad has made every possible effort to play its role in bringing stability in the region.
Geo News writes that he said, "Whoever tries to advance peace and security, we will stand with him."
In its coverage, after Malik's arrival in India, Geo News also gave space to Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinet, Congress leaders Surendra Rajput and Pramod Tiwari as well as Samajwadi Party's Fakhrul Hasan Chand and NCP's (Sharad Pawar faction) Clyde Crosto to raise questions.
Senior Congress spokesperson Supriya Shrinet had said, "The question is that Pakistan is accused of supporting terrorism, yet the Modi government is welcoming its representatives. Why can't your work be done without anti-India Pakistan?"
The News Pakistan has written that Musadiq Malik said on Saturday that there are many centers of instability in the region and expressed hope that sitting together of the countries will help in improving the situation.
The newspaper writes, "While speaking to the media on the sidelines of the SCO forum, he said that we should focus on solving problems instead of blaming each other. Pakistan will support every effort to promote peace and stability in the region."
Before his address, Malik held separate meetings with officials of Iran and Tajikistan on the sidelines of the SCO forum.
He also made several proposals including the establishment of a Virtual Green University to promote cooperation and research in climate culture.
According to reports of Indian news agencies, Mussadiq Malik's wife visited Dilli Haat in New Delhi and did shopping there.
He saw the open craft market and food plaza of Dilli Haat.
Dilli Haat is a cultural center known for traditional Indian handicrafts, regional artefacts, clothing and food.
Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.
Download the new BBC World Service app
Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place
Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
short video
end of short video




