Image source: Getty Images
When US President Donald Trump reached the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen, Chinese President Xi Jinping himself was present to welcome him.
But before this, when Russian President Vladimir Putin arrived, the responsibility of welcoming him was taken up by Xi Jinping's Chief of Staff and one of the top leaders of the Communist Party.
Hong Kong's leading media outlet South China Morning Post wrote in its report, "The last time a Chinese head of state welcomed a foreign leader by approaching an aircraft at the airport was in 1959."
"At that time, China's supreme leader Mao Zedong had arrived at Beijing Airport to welcome Soviet Union leader Nikita Khrushchev. Khrushchev's visit was confidential and at that time there was an atmosphere of strategic distrust between the two countries.
SCMP has written, "But this time the scene was completely different." When Trump descended the stairs of Air Force One, the leaders of the world's two most powerful countries embraced each other in front of the cameras. It is very rare for Xi Jinping to show such affection in public.
"After this, five J-10C fighter planes of the August First Aerobatic Team of China's People's Liberation Army Air Force flew over the airport. The planes left streaks of colored smoke in the sky. China wants to send a clear message that the extraordinary honor given to Trump was a demonstration of its commitment to the principle of mutual respect.
Did Xi give more importance to Trump than Putin?
Does this mean that Trump is more important to Xi Jinping than Putin, whom he calls his 'old friend'?
Anton Gerashchenko, a former adviser to Ukraine's Home Ministry, posted a photo of Xi Jinping and Trump hugging at the airport along with a photo of a junior Chinese official standing to welcome Putin, writing, "Putin was publicly humiliated in China."
End
Special stories selected for you by Nitin Srivastava
Learn more
"The Russian President was welcomed by Kai Chi, head of the General Office of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China. Kai Chi is 20 centimeters taller than Putin. Putin appeared before them as if he was the leader of a subordinate country. They were shown their status.
Anton has written, "When US President Donald Trump reached Shenzhen to attend the APEC summit, Chinese President Xi Jinping himself arrived to welcome him. Despite being an ally of Russia, Putin received a much lower level of reception than Trump. This was a clear signal from Beijing that Russia's position in relations with China is that of a subordinate partner. Russia's government propaganda machinery and media outlets avoided showing scenes of this meeting. They only broadcast footage of Putin's plane landing."
Xi Jinping's warm welcome towards Trump shows how serious China is about managing its relations with Washington.
Thomas Grove, Russia Bureau Chief of the American newspaper Wall Street Journal, wrote in a report, "China is America's biggest strategic rival and its economy is much larger than Russia's." After Russia's attack on Ukraine, China has provided great support to Moscow by providing financial assistance. But this meeting also made it clear that Beijing takes decisions according to its priorities and not just according to Putin's diplomatic agenda.
Thomas has written, "For Putin, this summit did not achieve any major policy achievements, but this does not reduce its political importance." This conference was widely publicized in Russia and received wide coverage in the media.
"This gave Putin an opportunity to show that despite his weak position, he can achieve strategic success at the diplomatic level. Images of Putin sitting with Trump and Xi Jinping and Trump publicly embracing the Russian president became a powerful symbol for the Kremlin. This helped convey the message that Russia's importance in global affairs still remains intact.
What are the experts saying?
Abbas Galyamov, a political analyst and Putin's former speechwriter, told the Wall Street Journal, "Putin's return and the possibility of this meeting are almost entirely due to Trump. When the president of the most powerful country in the world is treating you as an equal, it becomes difficult to keep someone isolated at the international level."
Galyamov said, "Under Putin's rule, Russia is now getting closer to the Soviet Union. It is making many achievements at the strategic level, but strategically its decline continues."
However, some analysts say that appearances and symbols are important in diplomacy, but they do not always indicate any major change in policies.
Dominic Chiu, senior analyst at Eurasia Group, told American newspaper The Philadelphia Inquirer, "We should not give too much importance to this development, nor should we conclude that Beijing is leaning towards Washington at the expense of Moscow. Behind this difference is China's diplomatic strategy."
According to Dominic Chiu, Xi Jinping himself arriving to welcome Trump could be a sign that China wants to maintain stable relations with America. This may also be a welcome keeping in mind Trump's tendency to give a lot of importance to respect and positive public image.
This was also a response to the welcome extended by the US President. In September, Trump himself arrived at America's Joint Base Andrews to welcome Xi Jinping.
He said that the partnership between China and Russia is already strong and established. Xi Jinping and Putin know each other well and the two leaders have met more often than they have with Trump.
"If anything, there is probably an unspoken understanding between Xi Jinping and Putin that they both need to carefully manage their relationship with Trump, even if that means accepting relatively little formal welcome from each other," Chiu said.
Yun Sun, director of the China Program at the Stimson Center, also believes that this difference in reception will not have any negative impact on relations between China and Russia.
He said, "China needs both America and Russia, but for different reasons. There is a need to manage relations with America, while Russia is China's partner. It is like comparing apples and oranges."
Ryan Haas, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, told news agency AFP, "Xi Jinping placed himself at the center of this entire event. He played a decisive role among the superpowers and became the organizer of this meeting. Pictures of this event will further strengthen Xi Jinping's political position. Beijing's main objective is to maintain the ongoing fragile peace and stability with the United States. So Xi Jinping will look for ways to show respect to Trump. "
He said Xi presented himself as a leader playing a central role among the superpowers and a key convener of meetings.
The 'Declaration of Peace' issued by the three countries after the meeting included many of China's old positions. These also include China's demand for reform in multilateral institutions like the United Nations.
Wang Yiwei, director of the Institute of International Affairs at Renmin University of China, said, "By building strategic consensus, these countries can promote comprehensive multilateral cooperation and set the direction for reshaping the global order and values."
Was Putin ignored during the group photo?
Before the welcome ceremony organized on Wednesday night, the three leaders arrived one by one for a group photo. He walked through a big hall to greet Xi Jinping.
Xi Jinping had a slight smile on his face. He shook hands with all the leaders one by one and there was not much change in his expression.
In contrast, Trump took more time during his meeting with Xi Jinping. After shaking hands, he paused for a while to get photographed with Xi in front of the cameras.
His meeting with Putin ended quite quickly. Xi Jinping welcomed him with a light smile, turned towards the cameras and then the meeting ended.
Just before the group photo, Putin tried to talk to Trump, but his conversation could not be completed. Both Trump and Xi Jinping pointed towards the place where Putin was to stand. Xi Jinping's wife was standing between the two leaders.
The three leaders were sitting at a round table in a room of a villa used to welcome government guests. Trump was sitting on the left side of Xi Jinping and Putin was sitting on the right side.
Xi Jinping said, "I am pleased to hold a trilateral meeting with President Putin and President Trump in Shenzhen."
According to China, the leaders of the three countries agreed to support reforms in the United Nations. These three countries have permanent membership in the United Nations Security Council.
In addition, it was also agreed to continue negotiations to increase fuel supplies and reduce the risks associated with nuclear weapons.
The American newspaper New York Times has written in its report, "In Shenzhen, Trump continued his efforts to include Russia again in the group of the world's major superpowers." He called Putin his friend and stressed that all three leaders want the war to end soon. However, after the meeting the Russian President once again reiterated that he will not negotiate with Ukraine.
In his address, Putin said, "Our countries are united not only because they were victorious in the Second World War, but most importantly, the common responsibility for maintaining international peace and security also binds us together."
Published by Collective Newsroom for the BBC.
Download the new BBC World Service app
Choose BBC News Hindi and get news alerts, live TV, podcasts... all in one place
Please note: The new app is not available in the UK and US.
short video
end of short video




