Image source: Reuters
Nearly nine years after the military in Myanmar killed thousands of the country's Rohingya Muslim minority, the United Nations International Court of Justice issued a decision deeming these practices "genocide," which places this decision among the landmark rulings.
The ruling by a panel of 15 judges from around the world marks the first time a country has been found guilty of this crime in an international court, and could have ramifications for other genocide cases, such as the case South Africa brought against Israel over the war in Gaza.
"intent to exterminate"
In response to the events of the Holocaust, the United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide was adopted in 1948 and entered into force in 1951, making genocide a crime under international law. During World War II, six million Jews and millions of other minorities were killed.
Genocide is defined as “acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group,” and is the most serious crime committed against humanity.
But conviction requires judges to meet strict evidentiary standards to prove genocidal intent, which is extremely difficult, especially when the defendants' actions do not explicitly lead to genocide, as was the case when dealing with Nazi practices.
To date, only individuals have been convicted of genocide in international courts, including those involved in the killing of hundreds of thousands of members of the Tutsi minority in Rwanda in 1994, and the systematic killing of thousands of Bosnian Muslim men and youth in Srebrenica in 1995.
They were convicted before special courts formed for this purpose.
But while individuals were found guilty of genocide in the Srebrenica massacre, the International Court of Justice, after a 14-year case, concluded that there was insufficient evidence to prove that the Serbian state had genocidal intent despite its failure to prevent the killings.
Most read end
The International Court of Justice cannot issue rulings against individuals, but only against states.
Myanmar is the first country ever found to have violated the 1948 Genocide Convention.
"Intent to destroy"
Stay updated with the latest current affairs
Download the app
BBC Arabic application for mobile phones
In 2017, the International Court of Justice found that a brutal military crackdown in Myanmar resulted in the deaths of 10,000 members of the Rohingya Muslim minority while more than 700,000 people fled to neighboring Bangladesh.
Two years later, Gambia filed a case before the International Court of Justice accusing Myanmar of committing genocide in the form of mass killings and acts of sexual violence against civilians, as well as the destruction of villages, accusations that Myanmar denied.
Myanmar has maintained that its measures were targeting Rohingya militants. A government representative told the international court earlier this year that it was not possible for Myanmar to "stand idly by and allow terrorists to move freely in northern Rakhine State."
While the president of the court, Yuji Iwasawa, acknowledged that there had been attacks by the Rohingya armed group ARSA prior to August 2017, Iwasawa said that security forces in Myanmar “killed thousands of Rohingya civilians” as they attempted to flee to Bangladesh.
He added that the scale and nature of the measures taken by Myanmar "reflected the intent to kill large numbers" of the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State.
Iwasawa ruled that Myanmar had "massively suppressed evidence" by burning or disposing of bodies in other ways, and failed to investigate, prosecute and punish perpetrators of genocide.
He said that the court recognizes the possibility of holding a state responsible for genocide or other acts if they are committed by “its agencies or by persons or groups whose actions are attributed to it.” He added that while individuals bear criminal responsibility, states have legal obligations.
Rohingya rights activist Yasminullah, speaking to the BBC's "Newsday" program prior to the issuance of this ruling, described this day as "a historic day for the Rohingya people."
She said she and her family were among those forced to flee their homes, and that she grew up in Thailand “with no legal status” before moving to Canada.
However, she warned that “justice may not be achieved unless it brings about an actual change in people’s lives,” calling for Myanmar to be held accountable, compensation paid, and the rights of the Rohingya restored to allow their “safe, voluntary and dignified return to their homes.”
The International Court of Justice is not a criminal court, and its executive powers are limited. It cannot send military officials to prison, and relies on the UN Security Council and political pressure to enforce its rulings.
Conclusive evidence
The International Court of Justice rarely hears genocide cases, so this ruling sets a precedent for future rulings that may benefit from it.
Maria Elena Vignoli of Human Rights Watch said the ruling “sets an important precedent for victims of genocide and other grave crimes around the world in their pursuit of justice.”
This case shows how intent to exterminate can be proven before the highest court of the United Nations.
Oliver Windridge, a former UN lawyer, told BBC News that the ruling highlights that a state can be held liable even when evidence of extermination intent is largely circumstantial, rather than based on an explicit written order or stated policy.
He added that the ruling "shows how the existing legal standard can be met when the evidence is sufficiently convincing."
Furthermore, Gambia took the case to court even though its citizens were not directly affected. It was based on a clause in the Genocide Convention that allows any state party to the convention to file a lawsuit against another member state.
This is the same clause that South Africa used in late 2023 when it filed a lawsuit accusing Israel of committing genocide during the war on Gaza, alleging that it sought “to destroy the Palestinians in Gaza.”
Israel insists on denying these accusations, describing the case as “completely baseless” and based on “biased and false allegations” regarding its military response to the Hamas attack on the country.
In an interim ruling issued in January this year, the International Court of Justice ruled that Israel must take all necessary measures to prevent genocide in Gaza, but stopped short of ordering an immediate halt to military operations.
The court has not yet decided whether genocide occurred or not.
Philip Sands KC, a member of the legal team representing The Gambia, said: “If The Gambia had lost the case, the South African case would have effectively ended.”
But he added that today's ruling means that "the door is still open," in an interview with the BBC's World at One program from outside the court.
He said: "This does not mean that the International Court of Justice will conclude that genocide occurred in Gaza. Rather, it means that the standard of proof has been very clearly defined, and the parties to the upcoming case and other cases will have to meet those standards."
But Sands stressed that the court was keen to "send a very strong signal that each case is decided on its own facts."
Find out more
Short clips
End of short clips




