Have you heard of Nervo, the Australian electronic music duo? The name is the last name of twins Olivia and Miriam, or Liv and Mim, as their fans call them. And they have many: they are two of the most successful female DJs on the planet, as well as producers and songwriters who have topped charts, headlined festivals, and won a Grammy.
But, 10 years ago, something happened that changed everything. Liv met someone. Someone special, someone different... your better half, the love of your life.
This is the story of how a woman was deceived on a large scale, not by force or threats, but in a much more subtle way.
Her experience raises uncomfortable questions about sex and consent.
His story is not unique and precisely for this reason he is now at the center of a campaign to change the law in England, which has had an echo internationally, generating reactions in several Latin American countries.
"It is very important, for the public good, that Olivia Nervo's story is heard," declared British MP Natalie Fleet.
This is how Liv told the BBC what happened to her.
From "hello" to "forever"
Liv and Mim grew up in Melbourne, Australia, and moved to the UK when they turned 19.
End of Most read
For a long time they weren't doing well with music, but Liv says: "Everything changed when we wrote a song for David Guetta: When Love Takes Over... We were so romantic!"
From then on, they began to live in full effervescence: they composed, went on tour around the world and took advantage of every opportunity.
In 2016, they were invited to perform on British tycoon Richard Branson's private island in the Caribbean during a charity event where millionaires paid fortunes to share the court with tennis stars and dine at sunset by the sea.
image copyrightGetty Images
All the news you need is on BBC World Service
Download it here
End of Ad app
It was there that Liv met Matthew Pringle, a businessman member of one of New Zealand's wealthiest families and director of a successful manuka honey business.
"I thought he was charming. We talked for about 40 minutes and suddenly he said to me: 'I think I'm in love'. I thought: 'What a fool!' But, at the same time, he seemed so sweet..."
The connection was immediate.
"We started talking every day. With Mim, we did between 120 and 150 presentations a year. We lived traveling and he flew 24 or 48 hours just to see me wherever I was," he says.
"When I offered to go visit him, he would tell me: 'Don't worry, you're really busy. I'm very proud of you, look at everything you're accomplishing!'. He always made me feel good, he encouraged me a lot. I felt very lucky."
Liv says that the relationship progressed very quickly, but in a very natural way, and they soon talked about the future.
"I asked him, 'What do you want for your life? Do you want to have children?' He said, 'I'm so glad you brought this up! I want to start a family and everything that entails.'"
Two red lines
As sweeping romances tend to be, theirs was intoxicating.
Matthew left love notes in her suitcase and sent her messages like: "I want to build our future together" or "I love you forever, for life."
Furthermore, he showed himself to be a man of very firm principles, who hated infidelity because, as he told her, he had suffered it firsthand.
Everything was very intense, but Liv was madly in love and let herself be carried away by the romance. And she wasn't the only one: those around her had also fallen in love with Matthew.
"My friends and family loved it. When I was on tour, he would go visit my 87-year-old grandmother," Liv says.
"It was like living permanently on a cloud. Never before had a man been so attentive and so fascinated by her," says Mim, who was a privileged witness to the romance.
Matthew had won over Liv's family, but she barely had contact with his.
He claimed to have a complicated relationship with his mother and even sent her screenshots of heated confrontations via message. They tried to meet her a couple of times, but it never happened.
Liv visited Matthew's house several times, but then he decided to rent it.
"It made sense: why would he want to have that house empty if he was with me all the time? We talked about it in great detail: who the tenants were, why it had been so difficult to rent it..."
About a year and a half into the relationship, they decided to try to have a baby.
"You're going to be the best mom in the world, darling," Matthew wrote. "I want you to get pregnant. I want you to be a part of my life."
In the summer of 2018, they began using a fertility app to increase their chances of getting pregnant. Matthew took a plane to be with her during her most fertile days.
After several months, the two red lines finally appeared on the pregnancy test.
"It was a wonderful moment... We were so happy, we were jumping for joy," Liv recalls.
At that time, no one suspected that the image that Matthew had constructed of himself might not be entirely true.
He starts to change
Soon, Matthew was no longer so present.
"It made me so angry that Liv didn't call him out on what he did. If she did, he would stop talking to her. Then Liv would get angry with me for being angry with her. It was a horrible cycle," Mim says.
The situation came to a head in December 2018, when Liv was four months pregnant. They had an ultrasound in Melbourne and planned to reveal the baby's sex to their family at Christmas. But, at the last minute, Matthew said he wouldn't be going.
"She said, 'I can't do it. You're making me too anxious.' I begged her and she stopped answering my calls. It devastated me. I spent the whole Christmas crying and started considering having an abortion, because I was like, 'I don't want to do this alone.'"
It was the second Christmas he had been invited to and he was missing.
After New Year's, Matthew and Liv met in a park.
"It was the first time I cried in front of him. I suggested: 'Let's have an abortion and put everything on hold. If you're scared, it's okay, really.' But he replied: 'No, I'm so sorry. You're not going to be a single mother. Don't talk nonsense. You're probably very sensitive about the pregnancy. It's all my fault.' And I believed him."
Mim says that the situation was deeply affecting her sister: "She had less confidence in herself and lived in fear. She was getting smaller and smaller and I could see it."
Liv's mother was also worried. The baby's father was conspicuous by his absence and he began to imagine the worst scenarios: drugs? An affair? He decided to hire a private investigator.
Meanwhile, Liv and Matthew mended their relationship, and even began looking for a house in London.
In February 2019, more than six months pregnant, Liv received a call from her mother. He had information from the detective and asked him to call Matthew to ask where he was. He told her he was picking up a package.
"I called my mom and said, 'It's at DHL.' She sent me a photo and said, 'It's not at DHL. It's at this address.' She also sent me several photos of him leaving the house he was supposedly renting. I said, 'Mom, you're completely crazy!'
"But my mom wasn't crazy."
"Who the hell are you?"
Liv, distraught and confused, traveled to New Zealand.
"He had told me he was staying with his grandfather, but when I arrived, he told me he was in a hotel."
On Matthew's phone he found missed calls from different women late at night. He said they were work matters.
"The contradictions were quickly accumulating. For the first time, I began to be alert. And to get scared: I didn't sleep all night."
The next morning, she insisted on accompanying him to work, where she ran into the sister of a woman who was at the hospital giving birth to his baby at the time.
She had been sent to look for him because he had not come home the night before.
Liv says, "I told her, 'I'm six and a half months pregnant,' and I showed her my belly. I'll never forget her expression, her eyes... she was really shocked."
Matthew denied everything and called a taxi. "He told me he'd be right back. But I said, 'Don't even think about leaving me here! I need to know what the hell is going on. Who the hell are you?'"
Liv got in the taxi with him, heading to the hospital, and shared her real-time location with her sister, who was in London.
"He was completely out of it," Mim recalls. "I told him to breathe, keep the location on, and take photos and record everything."
Meanwhile Matthew asked her to trust him, that he could explain everything to her. When he arrived, he gave him his wallet to pay for the taxi. When he returned, he called his mother.
"He said, 'Mom, I screwed up.' I took the phone from her and said to her mom, 'It's Liv.' And she said, 'Who?'
"All those messages where he said, 'Mom, Liv is someone very special to me,' and she had no idea who I was!" she says.
Heading to Matthew's mother's house, a panicked Liv recorded the conversation:
MATTHEW: I was afraid that if I told you, you would leave.
LIV: And what were you planning to do?
MATTHEW: I was going to tell you.
LIV: When?
MATTHEW: After the baby was born.
LIV: You set me up.
MATTHEW: I didn't mean to.
LIV: I even asked you if we should have an abortion. And you said no.
MATTHEW: I don't want you to do it.
LIV: So what? What does that mean? (...) I have a wonderful family. I have a wonderful life. And I fell into the hands of a damn scammer.
The true love of his life
When they arrived at Matthew's mother's house, he insisted that she stay in the taxi.
While waiting, Liv found in Matthew's wallet a photo of him with another woman, her hand lovingly resting on his chest.
On the threshold of his mother's house, he confessed that all the supposed communication with his mother had been written from another phone. He had posed as her and simulated discussions between the two, with abrupt telephone disagreements. All with such a level of detail that it was very convincing.
"And he kept telling me, 'It's not what it seems. I love you.'"
As for the person who appeared in the photo he had found, he discovered that it was a third woman: Liv was not the only one Matthew had kept hidden for years.
He returned to London.
"I even had suicidal thoughts. I had never had them before, but it was so devastating that I wanted to put an end to it. My friends were very supportive, but I spent the whole day crying," she says.
"Little by little I began to assume that I was going to be a single mother."
The girl was born and from that moment she became Liv's adoration.
"She is wonderful, hilarious, very loving and very sincere. I love her great ideas. You discover a way of loving that you never imagined was possible. I feel immensely lucky to be a mother," she says.
Even so, she finds it difficult to accept the circumstances in which she was conceived.
"All of this carries a burden of shame and stigma," he says. "When I tell it, a part of me feels that it is wrong, because I don't want it to be confused with the fact that I didn't want to have my daughter: I loved her and I love her. She is the great love of my life."
Still, it's a throwback to when she was being "absolutely manipulated."
We contacted Matthew Pringle to offer him the opportunity to give his side of the story. He did not answer, although he had previously acknowledged that he had not been sincere and had apologized for having deceived her.
"He wanted to silence me"
Matthew did not go to meet the girl after the birth. Over the phone, he said he wanted to contribute to her support and participate in her life. Although Liv didn't trust him, she didn't want her daughter to grow up feeling abandoned.
The tone changed when Liv began speaking publicly about what happened on Instagram. Then the lawyers entered the scene.
In exchange for almost a million dollars, Matthew asked her to sign a confidentiality agreement, which would have prevented her from revealing that they had been in a relationship, that he was the father of her daughter, or from contacting her family without his written authorization.
"I found it disgusting," Liv says.
Over the next few years, Liv received several letters from lawyers accusing her of defamation or threatening her with legal action for breach of privacy.
Although the threats did not materialize, he says: "I was always afraid, because I felt that he wanted to silence me at all costs."
Finally, in 2022, Matthew began proceedings before the London family courts, limiting during the proceedings what she could say in public.
At the beginning of this year, however, the situation changed, and she can now tell her story as part of her fight to give visibility to this problem.
Without consent
At first, she didn't quite understand what happened.
But one night, she came across an episode of the BBC program File on 4 Investigates, about a little-known form of intimate partner abuse: reproductive coercion.
There is no single definition, but the British Medical Journal described it as "any deliberate attempt to dictate a woman's reproductive decisions or interfere with her reproductive autonomy."
Specialists explain that it can take many forms: from pressuring her not to use contraceptives to coercing her to terminate or continue a pregnancy.
Liv believes that what she experienced was reproductive coercion, "because I was coerced into having a child with that man."
"It's all about control and keeping yourself vulnerable," he explains.
"He himself told me that he knew that if I found out the truth, I would break up with him. Keeping me by his side, even through coercion and deception, was more important to him than the consequences. The only way to keep me was with that whole plot of lies and pregnancy."
Although reproductive coercion is legally recognized as a form of controlling or coercive behavior, Liv believes it should be classified as a specific crime.
She works with the legal advocacy organization The Good Law Project and, in March of this year, she was invited to Parliament to attend a debate promoted by MP Fleet.
"Liv did not have the opportunity to give informed consent to the pregnancy, because she was lied to and deceived for years. This is reproductive coercion," Fleet declared in the House of Commons.
"There are cases like Liv's where there is evidence of what happened and yet no one is able to put a name to it. That has to change."
The government announced that it plans to more explicitly recognize reproductive coercion.
But Liv believes that her case also raises another fundamental question.
"How can you give your consent if everything you base that consent on is false?" he questions.
"I would never have consented to a sexual relationship with him, much less a planned pregnancy, if I had known the truth. I did not give my consent. I did not give informed consent."
¿Criminalizando la infidelidad?
Junto con varios expertos jurídicos, Liv reclama ahora la creación de una nueva figura delictiva, denominada sex by deception (relaciones sexuales mediante engaño), que penalizaría obtener el consentimiento sexual de otra persona mediante mentiras deliberadas.
"Es fundamental que las personas puedan tomar decisiones informadas sobre qué hacer con su propio cuerpo y con quién hacerlo", explica Paul Jarvis, abogado penalista del grupo Criminal Law Reform Now Network.
"Hay muchas otras situaciones en las que la ley sí considera delictivos el engaño y la mentira, como ocurre con el robo o el fraude. Sin embargo, cuando se trata de decisiones sobre nuestro propio cuerpo, el derecho penal apenas se ha pronunciado. En mi opinión, las leyes actuales están dejando desprotegidas a las víctimas".
La campaña está en una fase inicial. Entre las conductas que podrían quedar incluidas, y que previsiblemente suscitarán controversia, estarían mentir sobre el estado civil o sobre la propia identidad.
La clave sería determinar si la persona que miente sabe que, de haber conocido la verdad, la otra parte habría descartado mantener relaciones sexuales con ella.
"No estamos hablando de frases de conquista en un bar ni de mentirillas. Tampoco pretendemos criminalizar la infidelidad. Para que se considere delito, tiene que existir un engaño deliberado", dice Jarvis.
"Si alguien mantiene durante un periodo prolongado una segunda relación a espaldas de su pareja, estamos ante una conducta capaz de socavar significativamente su autonomía y su decisión de continuar o no la relación. Y si de esa situación se deriva un embarazo, las consecuencias para la mujer son muy reales", agrega.
Contactamos Matthew Pringle para que respondiera a la opinión de Liv de que había sido víctima de coerción reproductiva y de relaciones sexuales bajo engaño. No contestó.
Matthew conoció a su hija casi cuatro años después de su nacimiento y contribuye a su manutención con una cantidad mensual. El último encuentro entre ambos tuvo lugar hace dos años.
Liv planea seguir aprovechando su visibilidad pública para dar voz a quienes no la tienen y subraya que su hija es su principal motivación.
"Quiero que lo que nos sucedió a mi hija y a mí deje de estar asociado a cualquier sentimiento de vergüenza. No tenemos absolutamente nada de lo que avergonzarnos", dice.
"Espero que algún día, cuando mi hija mire atrás, pueda decir: 'Estoy orgullosa de que mi madre llamara a las cosas por su nombre y de que alzara la voz'".
Descubre más
Video
Fin de Video




