The dish itself is undeniably popular, and the lines between camps and terminology are not always clear

Tell us: do you have a special food tradition to ring in the new year?

Thanksgiving is a holiday of strong culinary convictions. Americans argue about whether marshmallows belong on sweet potatoes; whether green bean casserole counts as a vegetable; and, perhaps most insistently, whether that humble side of herbed, cubed bread should be called “stuffing” or “dressing”.

The dish itself is undeniably popular; the 2025 Roots & Recipes report by turkey brand Jennie-O found that 69% of 5,000 surveyed Americans identified it as a favorite side dish. But while some people proudly declare themselves #TeamStuffing or #TeamDressing, the actual distinction between the two is considerably less straightforward.

At first glance, it seems simple enough: if it’s cooked in the bird, it’s stuffing, right? Many members of #TeamDressing will tell you there’s no question for them, saying dressing is just safer (in an informal Facebook poll I conducted regarding people’s preferences, one longtime friend simply responded: “I look at stuffing and say: ‘Not today, food poisoning’”).

The cooking method does matter. “For optimal safety and uniform doneness, cook stuffing separately,” the US Department of Agriculture advises. Stuffing cooked inside the bird can absorb juices containing harmful bacteria, including salmonella. To ensure those bacteria are killed, the agency recommends using a food thermometer to ensure the center of the stuffing reaches at least 165F.

Preparation aside, the lines between camps and terminology are not always clear. Maybe they never have been. Butterball’s Turkey Talk-Line, which has fielded holiday cooking questions since 1981, acknowledges the ambiguity. “And yes, we’ve received countless questions about stuffing/dressing,” said its director, Nicole Johnson. She notes the terms are often used interchangeably, although dressing is more commonly associated with southern casseroles.

I tried to lasso turkey brand Jennie-O into the debate, but a spokesperson politely declined to take sides, explaining the company does not “have an official position on whether consumers should call the dish ‘stuffing’ or ‘dressing’”.

Even classic cookbooks don’t always draw a clear distinction. The 1950 Betty Crocker’s Picture Cook Book offers “stuffing tips” for filling poultry, then advises readers to form the leftover “dressing” into balls to bake individually.

Home cooks and eaters tend to judge on flavor and texture. Ali Whitman, general manager and co-owner of Bev’s Steak in Black Mountain, North Carolina, never cared much for dressing growing up. “I imagined it being some mushy, herby gloop,” she told me.

Not far away, in Blowing Rock, North Carolina, chef Kyle Martin owns Café Violette and Tout Suite Bakery with his wife, Sunshine. He grew up on Stove Top stuffing – a product that promised to remove the bird from the equation altogether when it first appeared in 1972.

Martin bakes his stuffing in a separate pan, finishing it uncovered in a hot oven “to get some textural crunch on the craggy surface”. Some would call it dressing. Martin won’t: “I’ll always call it stuffing, thanks to successful marketing!”

Meanwhile, Sunshine had an “extremely opinionated” grandmother who insisted on stuffing the turkey. Eventually, though, dressing (baked in a separate pan) joined stuffing (cooked inside the bird) at the family table. Both contained finely chopped turkey neck and giblets, and the mixture was never “too soggy”.

My own grandmother also stuffed it in the turkey, but only sometimes. Her recipe for what she called turkey dressing survives in a spiral-bound family cookbook, where a now-vintage droplet stains the line calling for one whole stick of butter. She specified 10 cups of cubed bread, but left it up to readers to intuit how much chicken stock to add.

She was one of those Americans who move between preparation styles with ease. In her neat cursive, she offered two preparation options in the family cookbook: “stuff turkey or bake in 13x9 pan.”

According to my mom, she sometimes took a third approach, forming individual dressing “cakes” that my dad would drown in velvety turkey gravy. Mom wasn’t impressed. “I remember he tried to get me to make them when we first got married,” she texted me recently. “And I said: ‘They’re hockey pucks, not dressing.’” She sent a follow-up buzz: “And it’s funny because I will interchangeably use the words ‘stuffing’ and ‘dressing’ the whole holiday season.”

Most viewed