The rapporteurs of the inspection mission triggered by the death of young Lyhanna pointed out on Monday a series of dysfunctions by investigators, in particular the gendarmerie, as well as the Auch public prosecutor's office.

Published on: 06/22/2026 - 7:58 p.m. Modified on: 06/22/2026 - 9:00 p.m.

“The urgency was not taken into account.” A series of dysfunctions among investigators were highlighted on Monday June 22 by the rapporteurs of the inspection mission triggered by the death of young Lyhanna, while Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu promised not to "give up" in the face of "an extremely serious truth".

Written by the General Inspectorate of the National Gendarmerie (IGGN) and that of Justice (IGJ), the highly anticipated report in this affair which caused a national stir was given to the Prime Minister, then published "anonymized".

He mentions "an accumulation of waste of time and a lack of follow-up of procedure, both on the part of the prosecution and the gendarmerie upon the arrival of the procedure at the Auch public prosecutor's office", declared the head of the IGJ Stéphane Nöel to the press in Matignon.

Jérôme Barella, the main suspect in the rape and death of Lyhanna, 11, who disappeared on May 29 in Gers, had never been worried until then even though he was notably targeted by a complaint filed in August by the mother of Rosa, a 10-year-old child who accused him of having raped her "around fifty times", according to the report.

This complaint was "not treated as a priority procedure": "The sensitive nature of the procedure was not relayed, the procedure was not directed towards the correct gendarmerie service", detailed Stéphane Nöel.

He also underlines "a lack of sufficient consideration of the emergency" with regard to the profile of Jérôme Barella, who was already the subject of several complaints for sexual assault and rape against children.

To readLyhanna affair: “dysfunctions” or lack of resources for justice in France?

Investigation against the Auch prosecutor

On

“Public power will not abdicate”, it must “precisely establish responsibilities and draw all the consequences, including individual ones”, he added, leaving the threat of sanctions hovering once again, while ensuring that he did not want to “cast opprobrium” on the gendarmerie and justice “as a whole”.

In a press release published Monday, the Minister of the Interior Laurent Nunez requested "a command investigation" to shed light on the responsibilities of each participant" in the handling of little Rosa's complaint in August 2025 and said he would like the "official transfer" of two gendarmes, who will no longer work in the judicial police.

The Minister of Justice, Gérald Darmanin, attracted the wrath of a number of magistrates for having pointed out individual dysfunctions from the very beginning, without waiting for the conclusions of the inspection mission.

Weakened by this affair which led to calls for his resignation from La France Insoumise (LFI) to the National Rally (RN) via the Socialist Party (PS), the Minister of Justice repeats that he bears no political responsibility, affirming that on the contrary, his directives to give priority to the treatment of cases of attacks on persons – in particular child crime – have not been fully applied. The magistrates' unions point to an avalanche of priorities and a glaring lack of resources.

Monday evening, the Minister of Justice announced the opening of an administrative investigation against the Auch prosecutor. “I am initiating a disciplinary procedure this evening, an administrative investigation which will be carried out before the end of the summer to initiate sanctions which will be commensurate with the serious failings observed for the substitute of the Auch public prosecutor's office,” declared the Minister of Justice on TF1.

Gérald Darmanin also reported “very significant failures” due to “personal failings” and not to lack of resources.

Pending the result of this investigation, expected "before the end of the summer", this magistrate was also withdrawn by the Minister of Justice "his authorization to carry out investigations and deal with cases concerning minors", added the minister's entourage, who once again evacuated the question of his resignation.

If it confirms errors or individual faults, this investigation opens the way to a referral to the Superior Council of the Judiciary (CSM), which will give an opinion before a sanction pronounced by the Minister of Justice.

The government wants to show that the first lessons from this affair have been learned: the urgent re-examination of 70,000 complaint files affecting children, with July 14 as the deadline, has already resulted in the placement of 134 people in pre-trial detention for sexual violence.

Lyhanna's death continues to fuel a series of mobilizations to demand better protection for victims of sexual and gender-based violence. New rallies were planned for Monday in front of several courts.

The anger of the families has not subsided either. One of them will file a complaint against the State for “gross negligence” and refer Gérald Darmanin to the Court of Justice of the Republic.

To seeArnaud Gallais: “children are systematically neglected in France”

“Untenable situation”

And, one year before the presidential election, political leaders are making their proposals. From compulsory chemical castration for Bruno Retailleau (Les Républicains) to new credits for justice on the left.

“If we stick to individual responses, by designating one or two scapegoats without tackling this scourge head-on (...), we will have completely missed the point,” said LFI coordinator Manuel Bompard on Sunday.

There are "perhaps" individual responsibilities, but the justice professions are "in an untenable situation", commented the boss of the Ecologists Marine Tondelier, Sébastien Chenu (RN), deploring that "Gérald Darmanin is still in place".

The executive is under pressure for a text to respond to the emergency: a so-called "integral" law of 78 articles supported by around a hundred deputies from the left and the government coalition.

On Monday, Sébastien Lecornu reiterated his priority of strengthening the child protection bill "during the very next council of ministers".

Calling for a global reform accompanied by reinforced resources, feminist and childhood defense associations reacted to the report of the rapporteurs of the inspection mission, affirming that the dysfunctions singled out in the Lyhanna affair are a reflection of “systemic problems”.

Also readLyhanna affair: the “Classified without further action” site allows victims of VSS to express their anger

“Coordinated and resourced response”

This pre-report describes an operation which is not specific to the public prosecutor's offices and the brigades of Toulouse and Auch, underlined during a press conference the associations (Face à l'inceste, the Women's Foundation, the CGT) of the coalition which calls for a "comprehensive law against sexual violence", joined by the SOS Périscolaire collective.

“This is the normal functioning of investigation services and justice which suffer from structural deficiencies (lack of training, lack of resources, lack of staff, etc.)”, they underline.

“The inspectors point out individual dysfunctions when it is a system which creates these dysfunctions,” reacted the director of the film “Les Chatouilles”, Andrea Bescond.

The associations are calling to gather every Monday evening in front of the courts in France and in front of the Ministry of Justice in Paris to demand a "comprehensive law" against violence against women and children until July 4. That day, they also called for demonstrations in France. If the government does not promote a comprehensive law, they will resume on September 7, announced Andréa Bescond, wearing a “We don’t give up” T-shirt.

The coalition criticizes the government's intention to add measures to the child protection bill which must be examined in mid-July in the Assembly, judging that it wants to "divide the associations".

“Only a coordinated, interministerial response with substantial resources will allow a paradigm shift,” they said.

With AFP

Keywords associated with the article

The content you are trying to access does not exist or is no longer available.